Ratings may include incentivized customer reviews.
What Customers Are Saying
Customers report widespread dissatisfaction with this rat trap, citing a trigger mechanism that fails to activate even when bait is consumed, allowing rats to steal food without setting it off. Many describe the trap as extremely difficult and dangerous to set, requiring 10 to 15 minutes and risking finger injuries from the heavy spring. Reviewers frequently compare it unfavorably to competitor brands, calling it unreliable and poor quality. A small number report successful catches and praise the sturdy construction, but these positive experiences are vastly outnumbered by complaints of ineffectiveness and poor design.
Customer review summary generated by AI, including incentivized reviews.This mouse trap does not work
Would Not RecommendThe only thing that this trap worked was to catch my hand in it when I was testing it to see if it is working. Until now the peanut butter was all eaten by the rats but I haven't seen any caught in this trap. I caught one rat yesterday and another one today using the Rat Snap Trap, so that one actually works, now I have to go and buy some other ones because I don't reuse them.
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
Extremely difficult to set
Would Not RecommendWish I had reviewed prior to purchase. I spent More time trying to set trap than rats do eating The food. Not 1 rat. Apparently not all traps are the same.
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
Go get Victor paddle traps
Would Not RecommendTL;DR: Get Victor M326 traps -- don't bother with these. First time dealing with a rat problem and boy have I learned a lot. I started out with four of these tomcat traps and they haven't caught a thing. I've had three instances of triggered without a catch and five instances of stolen bait (peanut butter). After the first two bait thefts I added some string looped through the end of trigger. You can imagine my surprise when I found the trap untriggered with my a pile of string shards next to i...
Don't waste your money
Would Not RecommendThe poison finally worked after a week. I coated the bait strip with peanut butter an it actually cleanly licked it off without tripping it.. it got cheese off with out tripping it , but the corker was last night when it was nearly dead i went to the kitchen and it was sitting on the trap licking peanut butter off again, I scared it and it hid but this morning it was dead. I wish I could have videoed it and put it on you tube, it would have gone viral LOL.
CHEAPCAT TRAPS
Would Not Recommendthe only reason i bought them is because LOWES DOES NOT SELL VICTOR TRAPS , i think they make the CHEAPCAT traps with old coat hangars.JUNK DO NOT BUY !!!!!!!
Sadly disappointed
Would Not RecommendWe've gone through 2 traps only to find them still set without the bait. We've used peanut butter only to find it licked clean, with chew marks all around. I've started to use cheese and it's completely gone, no evidence of it. Our rodent is getting very brave because within minutes of putting the trap down, the bait is gone and trap is still set. It's like we have a large dining plate for the rat. Might as well set up a bed for him, too.
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
We are sorry that the trap is not catching the rat as expected. We want you to be confident in our products. For this reason, we offer a product guar...
Poor quality
Would Not Recommend1st day Set up 6 traps with TOMCAT ATTRACTANT gel for 1 night and nothing happens 2nd day set up 6 traps with peanut butter and next morning the peanut butter disappear 3rd day I use dog food and use gluegun to hold on place The mechanism works but the springs are very weak and the rats escape (maybe laughng at this brand) I wasted time and little money
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
We are sorry that you have had a negative experience with the Tomcat Wooden Rat Trap. We appreciate you letting us know. We are not sure why these dif...
Doesn't work
Would Not RecommendI have a flat roof and have learned that poison is not an option. They seem to all die in the ceiling and cause weeks worth of bad smells. I bought 2 2packs of these baited and set them. The next morning, the bait was gone and the traps were still set. Tried to adjust them and still losing the peanut butter. I could not find a customer service contact on the website.
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
We apologize that our Tomcat Rat Snap Trap is not being triggered properly. While we aren't completely certain why this would be happening, some roden...
THIS TRAP SUCKS!!!!!!!
Would Not RecommendIt Would be more accurate to label them rat feeding stations. Bought the product last week been putting them out every night. Every morning I find my bait gone and a huge pile of droppings surrounding the trap. This morning there were droppings on the trap itself right under the trigger. Like the rat was just hanging out partying on the thing. On the bright side the trap provides a great place for single rats to meet other single rats. With free refreshments! Oh wait I'm making the problem worse...
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
We are sorry the Tomcat Wooden Rat Trap did not control the rats as expected. We cannot be sure why the bait is gone, and the trap is not being trigge...
Rats love the free food
Would Not RecommendPurchased the trap a couple of weeks ago, and have been giving the rats a feast since. We are using peanut butter and for some reason the trap isn't sensitive enough to spring. I found from these reviews that others are having the same problem. The way the bar attaches to the spring holder seems odd. This may be the problem. Hopefully someone from the Company will contact me with a solution, I'll wait and see
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
We are sorry the Tomcat Mouse Snap Traps did not function as expected. We are not sure why the traps would have not set properly or why the alignment ...
Sometimes tricky, but effective
Would RecommendStrong spring. I've got 5 big rats at this point. Trap is difficult to arm with a hair trigger so make sure bait needs to be pulled from trap. I shove sunflower seeds in bait area so they require force from the animal to remove. This thing killed 2 giant rats over the last two days. Setting trap takes getting used to.
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
not a single rat
Would Not Recommend14 traps and not one rat triggers licked clean some traps deployed no dead animal
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
We are sorry to hear that this product has not worked well for you. We cannot be sure why the bait is gone, and the trap is not being triggered. While...
Traps will not trip.
Would Not RecommendAs with so many other reviews, these traps are nothing more than dinner plates for rats and mice. I use these alongside a competitors traps, which kill several rodents every week. These traps have never tripped, yet the bait is gone every night.
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
We are sorry that this trap has not preformed up to your expectations. It is possible that if the rat is to light to activate the trap. However, we wa...
it worked
Would RecommendWe placed 2 traps with crushed aluminum foil. The next day we found the little thing with its' back broken. Poison and peanut butter did not work. the shiny stuff did. And, it is reusable if we need to use it again - just use pliers to open the trap to "empty" it.
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
Poorly Designed
Would Not RecommendI would not have purchased if I had read these reviews first, but at least I am not out a lot of money. These traps are poorly designed. The arming mechanism oddly shaped and doesn't work well.
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
We're sorry to hear of your disappointment in the design of our Tomcat® Wooden Rat Trap. When our product fails to meet your expectations it is our pr...
Garbage
10 traps licked clean. Used pliers to bend the trigger mechanism to try to make it more sensitive to Rats. Then 10 traps, several licked clean and several self deployed. So far, we have killed two rats out of several nights of setting 10 traps. Our terrier has killed three. Bottom line is these traps are horrible and do not work. Take your money and flush it before buying these.
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
We're troubled to hear of your experience with our Wooden Rat Trap. This is certainly not what we want you to expect with our product, and would welco...
this trap does not work
Would Not RecommendBought 5 traps and all of the traps set were licked clean. I rebaited them and again were licked clean. I had two old Victor rat traps that caught 7 rats while these tomcat traps were getting licked clean. When I set the trap off to rrebait them the springs would come undone and had to be reset also.
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
We would like to apologize for the lack of rat control you experienced when using our Rat Traps. This is certainly not what we want you to expect when...
Rats love this trap because it doesn't work
Would Not RecommendRats get free food. 3 times now in 24 hours the rats have clean off the peanut butter.
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
We are saddened to hear of your experience with our Rat Trap. This is obviously not the result we want you to have with our products. Unfortunately, i...
rats lick it clean and survive
We are having the same problem as everyone else. Rats lick it clean and no rats are caught. Both traps started with peanut butter last night and the rats had a feast.
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
We're troubled to hear of your experience with our TomCat Rat Trap. This is obviously not what we want you to expect with our traps. Sometimes the rod...

We are sorry to hear that the Tomcat Wooden Rat Trap did not kill the invasive rodents as expected. We are not sure why the trap is not being triggere...