Ratings may include incentivized customer reviews.
What Customers Are Saying
Customers report widespread dissatisfaction with this rat trap, citing a trigger mechanism that fails to activate even when bait is consumed, allowing rats to steal food without setting it off. Many describe the trap as extremely difficult and dangerous to set, requiring 10 to 15 minutes and risking finger injuries from the heavy spring. Reviewers frequently compare it unfavorably to competitor brands, calling it unreliable and poor quality. A small number report successful catches and praise the sturdy construction, but these positive experiences are vastly outnumbered by complaints of ineffectiveness and poor design.
Customer review summary generated by AI, including incentivized reviews.Doesn't trigger
Would Not RecommendI typically don't write reviews, and I'm sorry to leave a bad one. The trap seems like its good quality, but the rats have licked the peanut butter clean off the trap without it activating. I thought I had a bad unit so I tried the second one that came in the package, and it had the same results. It's just not sensitive enough, and I ended up just feeding the rats the last few days.
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
Rat trap or rat feeder?
Would Not RecommendThese traps do not work. I set 2 traps. One with cheese and one with peanut butter. The next morning both baits were completely gone and neither trap was sprung. Tried again the next night. Same results. Very disappointed.
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
We are sorry to hear that one of your Tomcat Rat Traps did not capture a rat. The spring mechanism may have weakened and prevented the trap from relea...
poorly built
Would Not Recommendi have bought 8 of these traps in the past 2 months..only to have them fall apart after 1st couple use's...set them ,went back in the morning & trap has been sprung but no rat & no bait tray left on the trap whole metal peice totally gone staple & all .. think i'll stick to the brand iv'e always used before trying this brand..lost customer for life..worst product ever..6 out of 8 traps worthless
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
We are sorry to hear of the difficulties you encountered with Tomcat Rat Trap. This is not what we expect from this product, and we would be intereste...
Some Minor Adjustments and It Worked Great
Would RecommendThe first two times I used the trap the rat stole the peanut butter and dog food appetizer. After bending the hook holder more vertically to make the trap more sensitive, and by prying up the prong on the bait holder and wedging a flat piece of dog kibble under it I caught the rat within minutes.
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
Don’t even waste your time buying it!
Would Not RecommendI brought this trap today and spent over 30 mins trying to set it! The pin wouldn’t set in grove and it wouldn’t stay on top of the loop! Tried setting the 2nd trap and the same thing happened! The company made the video look so easy, but that wasn’t the case in reality! They need to make the hook on the bait easier to latch! Needless to say, I got so frustrated that I broke the baits part of the traps trying to hold it higher so that groove could match the pin! This product was a waste of tim...
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
We are sorry that you are disappointed with your purchase of Tomcat Rat Trap. As the product manufacturer, we are very interested in supplying consume...
Disappointed
Would Not RecommendWe are so disappointed with this trap. Not only does it like to trip as soon as you set it; often while still in your hand trying to trying to sit it down, they trip on their own (it was in the same room we were in and it snapped without a trigger.)
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
We apologize for your frustration regarding Tomcat Rat Trap. Your feedback is important to us, and we will pass this on to our Quality Assurance Team....
Finger breaker!
Would Not RecommendWhat a ridiculous design. Not unlike others of this design, but setting this trap is difficult and dangerous. Don’t buy this c—p.
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
Worthless
Would Not RecommendThey aren't even curved to hold the pin at all and when you bend it yourself the trap doesnt even work. Who in the world isnt doing their freaking job there
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
We apologize for your frustration regarding the Tomcat Wooden Rat Trap. This is not what we expect from this product, and we would be interested in di...
Reliable Trap
Would RecommendGreat Trap does the job Quickly! Use an adjustable clamp for wood. Set about 2inches open to hold the u-bar in place, then set trigger bar. ease the clamp off the bar with fingers on side or back of the trap.
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
tomcat rat trap
Would RecommendI use them every year and they work every time! Since I raise chickens and the food sometime spilled around the garden, hence the rats.
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
Rat feeder instead of trap
After buying three of the wooden traps for larger rats and every day replacing the bait I’ve thrown them away. Bait consistently gone without the trap going off. Well except while setting it. I bought another brand similar and have had very good success. The way the trip wire latches is unreliable at best. The Tomcat brand has always been a favorite of mine and I will continue to buy the glue pads and bait, however I cannot recommend the trap.
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
We are troubled to hear that you encountered an issue with Tomcat Wooden Rat Trap. Anytime we hear problems encountered in the use of one of our produ...
Difficult to set - CRAP
Difficult to set cheaply made easy to set off while laying on the floor crap crap crap go ahead and go get yourself a victor trap.
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
We are sorry to hear of your experience with Tomcat Wooden Rat Trap. As the product manufacturer, we strive to supply consumers with quality products ...
Does work - but needs updating
To Tomcat Co. You need to update your policy on recycling practices: 1-Packaging needs to specify if either the product and/or the packaging is made of recycled material; 2-A note on the packaging or product must specify how to recycle both; they should be recyclable (where are the icons?). In regards to performance: I have used these a lot of over the years, and caught rats. But i'll be looking for another brand if Tomcat does not update recycling information. Thank you.
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
Smashed it on the Curb
Would Not RecommendI literally got up and went outside and smashed it on the curb. Sure, I probably have anger management issue, but aside from that this design is completely awful. Others have said their’s weren’t sensitive enough, but mine were impossible to set, the pin didn’t grab into the slot enough. I tried for 20 minutes before I was fed up. Smashed it on the curb which put my heart at peace, and went down to Ace and bought some victor traps which set perfectly and easily with one try every time. Caught ra...
I Like the large size, Easy to set and remove mice
[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I really like the large size. It was easy to set and easy to remove the dead mice. The large size also makes it easy to see in a storage area.
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
good design
[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] fast / quick acting, powerful spring. long lasting.
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
it works in its first use
Would Recommendit works pretty nice, the first time. I bought two. one place on kitchen counter and one on kitchen floor. use a pea size peanut butter as bait. the next morning, the one on the floor has a nice catch. see attached.
Do not buy
Would Not RecommendThese traps are horrible. I can’t believe Lowe’s and others sell them. I wish I had read reviews before buying them. But- it’s just a larger mouse trap- who reads the reviews for a mouse or rat trap. I hope others do. To start, they are hands down the most difficult traps I’ve ever set. They are actually dangerous. They are super sensitive when trying to set. I finally got them set (took over 30 minutes to set three without losing a finger) and went to bed. Before falling asleep I heard one snap...
One Star is too Much Credit
This was a terrible product. I had so much trouble setting it, and then found out that the pin didn't fit right. I had to get out the pliers and bend it a bit. This should come ready to go. I shouldn't have to do their job. Someone is slacking on their end. I did get it working. They are set, and I returned two that I didn't open. I bought two Victor traps. They even look better made. I actually like the one that's easier to set up; less chance of breaking a finger for a dollar more. Two bad peo...
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
Product failure.
Your attempt to replicate the tried and true, wood & steel, spring loaded rat trap sucks. They fall apart under the force of the spring, due to weak construction. Inferior product.
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
We are sorry that you are disappointed with your purchase of Tomcat Wooden Rat Trap. As the product manufacturer, we strive to supply consumers with ...

We are sorry to hear that you had a poor experience with Tomcat Wooden Rat Trap. We would be interested in hearing more about the issue so that we can...