Ratings may include incentivized customer reviews.
What Customers Are Saying
Customers report widespread dissatisfaction with this rat trap, citing a trigger mechanism that fails to activate even when bait is consumed, allowing rats to steal food without setting it off. Many describe the trap as extremely difficult and dangerous to set, requiring 10 to 15 minutes and risking finger injuries from the heavy spring. Reviewers frequently compare it unfavorably to competitor brands, calling it unreliable and poor quality. A small number report successful catches and praise the sturdy construction, but these positive experiences are vastly outnumbered by complaints of ineffectiveness and poor design.
Customer review summary generated by AI, including incentivized reviews.Poor instructions
The instructions are very hard to follow. It would be nice if there were a youtube video for this trap. Couldn't find one.
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
Impossibly hard to set. Not made as shown here.
Would Not RecommendFirst of all, whip out a calendar and see what year it is. (hint: 2025). Your level of instructions is more like 1925. Get a good camera! Make a video! Share a link! I think it comes down to the fact that the "Pin" is made wrong. It has a loop that is held by a staple. The other end, the free end, has a "curve". I would call it a zigzag. In a really bad picture taken from this site, you can see that the curve is at a right angle to the loop. In the picture of the one I just bought, the zigzag a...
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
We are sorry to read about your experience with the Tomcat Rat Trap. We would like the opportunity to gather some additional information and offer ass...
Not meet the expectation
i bought 6 of these trap. Caught 1 little mice. that’s it. These traps do not work. I set 6 traps. All with cheese The next morning 5 of baits were completely gone and neither trap was sprung. Tried again the next night. Same results. Very disappointed. The old ones worked much better.
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
We're sorry to read about your disappointment with Tomcat Rat Trap and appreciate your feedback. We want you to be confident in our products. For thi...
4 thumbs down
Would Not RecommendBetter odds of losing a finger than catching a rat. Take the brand name and simply invest in freeing cats. They do the best job. No finger traps or poison necessary
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
We are concerned to hear this. We would like the opportunity to gather some additional information and offer assistance. Please reach out to our Consu...
Garbage Trap- Do not Buy
Just tried to set it up and found out the the one metal part is punched backwards. Tried to bend it the proper way. Pull back the U Wire to set the pin over it and the pin bends. This is absolute garbage. I tried it 10 times, broke my finger.
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
We are concerned to hear this regarding the Tomcat Rat Trap. We would like the opportunity to gather some additional information and offer assistance....
Don’t waste your money on this junk
I bought 2 rat traps both are junk can’t set them they need adjustment and no where can I find instructions pretty bid waste of my hard earned dollars
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
We're sorry to read about your disappointment with Tomcat Rat Trap and appreciate your feedback. The trigger, on which the bait is placed, needs to b...
Three-pete staple problem
Would RecommendPurchased many in the past and all work well. Bought 2 back to back and both traps had the right side brass staple pulled out of the wood base. Just bought another one and hope it’s not a three-pete..
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
We are concerned to hear this. We would like the opportunity to gather some additional information and offer assistance. Please reach out to our Consu...
Terrible
Could not set the trap. We have set many traps, something is wrong with this one. Should not have to modify it.
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
We are concerned to hear this. We would like the opportunity to gather some additional information and offer assistance. Please reach out to our Consu...
Tomcat Rat trap
Would Recommend[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] The Tomcat Rat trap is a well made product. I use this trap on the boarder of my home because our neighbors have fruit trees and end up on the ground and rodents appear at times. It is very easy to use and I would recommend this product.
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
Good trap - bad instructions
It works well *if you set the trap correctly*. Their instructions are not clear. What you need to do on step 2 is *not* put the bent rod through the oblong hole (which is what I did at first- if you do that then the trap won’t ever trip and catch anything) but rather just set the end of the bent rod under the bent part of the oblong hole, parallel to the hole. Then the trap will go off when it’s supposed to.
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
Trap does not work
Would Not RecommendI followed the instructions and the trap will not release. rodent eats the bait and the trap remains set as directed. Design and setting is completely different from the smaller mouse trap that works.
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
Lorin, we're sorry to hear about your experience with the Tomcat Rat Trap and we'd like to help. Reach out to us here for assistance with our product ...
Kinda works
Would RecommendI put this out but did not use the recommended peanut butter or gel. I heard from an exterminator to use raw bacon rapped around the trigger. The first night I caught a rat, a Baltimore rat. Our rats here are quite large so while it injured the rat, it did not immediately kill it. This rat has been suffering for hours. I bought this so it would be an immediate kill.
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
We appreciate your feedback on the Tomcat Rat Traps. Reach out to us here for assistance with our product guarantee: https://tinyurl.com/ydb2q8sn
Save your money
Would Not RecommendThe guy who bends the trip mechanism needs to be given more time on the conveyor belt.
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
bob27, we're sorry to hear you weren't satisfied with Tomcat Wooden Rat Traps and we appreciate your feedback. Reach out to us here for assistance wit...
Poor quality Rat Trap
Would Not RecommendThis is one of the poorest made products I have ever bought. The pieces did not fit. Iwork over an hour with my tools to fix it. I finlly gave up. You should be ashamed to sell such a poor quality product.
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
We're sorry to hear about your experience with Tomcat Wooden Rat Traps and we appreciate your feedback. Our products are supported by a product guaran...
Frustrating!
Would Not RecommendOn the occasions that the traps actually sprung, they were strong enough for a quick kill. BUT, only two of ten actually sprung in the first set, and that has stayed fairly consistent average with subsequent sets. I toss the trap and rat in the garbage if it works and replace with new trap. My problem has been a consistent issue with the trap not being triggered. Like one reviewer noted, I've gently picked up unsprung traps that the bait has been eaten off, and they'll sometimes trip. Why t...
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
WilburB, we're sorry to hear Tomcat Wooden Rat Traps didn't work as expected. We'd like to offer our assistance with the product guarantee. Please rea...
Careful not to snap your hand
Would Recommend[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] These traps are definitely effective IF set carefully and properly. Have caught 7 mice with this and keeping it catch ready for more. Setting these traps are really fairly simple but must be put what your children and pets cannot get to them.
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
weak barely works
works fine on small young rats, larger adult rats will survive
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
We apologize that you were not thoroughly satisfied with Tomcat Rat Trap. If a rodent is not caught within 2-3 days we recommend moving the trap to a ...
Look similar to the Victor Traps but don’t work
Would Not RecommendI bought 6 of these traps as they look pretty sturdy. These just don’t catch anything. They’re very hard to set off. I’ve noticed peanut butter will be gone and nothing caught. You can add a little or a lot and nothing is caught. Fact is that these traps don’t work well.
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
We are sorry that you are disappointed with your purchase of Tomcat Wooden Rat Trap. We do have a product guarantee that covers all of our products t...
Impossible to Use
Would Not RecommendImpossible to use as directed. Directions are also impossible to understand and the photos are too small. Potentially dangerous because of how hard it is to set the trap.
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
Rats were able to take bait , trap didn’t activate
Would Not RecommendI bought a couple of these and they’re worthless, all 4 times I tried it, the peanut butter was LICKED CLEAN and the trap did not activate! Victor is much better and much more sensitive, Tom cat plastic snap traps are much better , avoid tomcats wooden trap, they don’t work
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
We apologize for your frustration regarding Tomcat Wooden Rat Trap. This is not what we expect from this product, and we would be interested in discus...

Hello Esteban, We're sorry to hear about your experience with the Tomcat Rat Trap and appreciate you taking the time to share your feedback. We want...