Ratings may include incentivized customer reviews.
What Customers Are Saying
Customers praise the trap's effectiveness at capturing mice alive, with many reporting catches of three to seven mice within days using peanut butter bait. The humane design strongly appeals to those opposed to lethal methods. However, significant drawbacks emerge: reviewers report false triggers with no mouse inside, mice escaping after partial activation, and bait theft without capture. Success depends heavily on proper placement and using minimal bait. While many find it effective, design flaws and inconsistent performance frustrate others, creating a divided customer base.
Customer review summary generated by AI, including incentivized reviews.Great humane trap
Would RecommendWould rather not kill the mouse if I don’t have to and this does the job
The bait door didn't properly fit
Would Not RecommendBait door didn't fit well and with the weight of the small amount of peanut butter it kept setting off the trap so it was a waste of money.
Caught 2 mice within 24 hours
Would RecommendI was skeptical about the effectiveness of this product after seeing mixed reviews but I purchased the product (3 of them to be exact) and caught 2 mice within 24 hours of having them set. We used chunky peanut butter as bait and that seemed to lure them in. My only suggestion is that I don’t think they work as well on carpet but we placed them on pieces of cardboard and that solved the problem.
It does catch mice!
Would RecommendEasy to use. Used peanut butter as bait. Released the mouse several miles away at the park.
No good for small mice / needs a heavier critter
Would Not RecommendThe chocolate def got a 2” mouse to get inside, but it scurried right back out (fed) as it wasn’t heavy enough to trigger the see-saw action & close the trap. Will be returning since it’s ineffective for my needs. Plastic parts maybe asily break—Lowes sold me a 2nd trap which already had a broken door hinge.
Was delivered broken
Would Not RecommendReceived item in a new box but product inside had a broken trap door so it never really worked
We would like to understand more about your experience and what we can do better. At your earliest convenience, please reach out to us at 877-332-075...

Even a small mouse can chew through
Would Not RecommendSet the trap in the evening & checked in the morning. Trap successfully caught a mouse, however the trap is thin plastic and the little guy chewed right through the side / bottom of it and escaped before I checked the trap.
We're sorry to read about your disappointment with Tomcat Live Catch Mouse Trap and appreciate your feedback.
This is very uncommon, b...

Works with a catch
Would RecommendWe had a field mouse tearing up our flower bed and gave this a try. The first 2 days it was a glorified feeder as the vole would get trapped, but would thrash his way into moving it and getting it open. Once I wised up and leaned a paver on it to weigh it down, it worked & he was caught and relocated the following morning
Hamster trap
Would RecommendWorked like a charm. Our new pet hamster escaped in the car and there was nowhere to be found. This mousetrap was able to catch him within a couple of hours.
Meh
Would Not RecommendEasy setup but didn’t work. A regular snap trap is what finally got the mouse.
We're sorry to read about your disappointment with Tomcat Live Catch Mouse Trap and appreciate your feedback.
We want you to be confid...

did not work
Would Not Recommendafter 10 days, not one mouse has entered the trap.
We're sorry to read about your disappointment with Tomcat Live Catch Mouse Trap and appreciate your feedback. If a rodent is not caught within 2-...

Did not work at all for me
Would Not RecommendSet four of them out and the mouse ate the peanut butter from all of them without the trap being triggered.
We are sorry to see that you were not completely satisfied with your purchase. We would like the opportunity to gather some additional information an...

Doesn't trip.
Would Not RecommendThe mouse in my garage has eaten the bait from this trap 5 times without tripping it. I loaded the end cap up with peanut butter and the mouse completely cleaned it without tripping the trap.
We are sorry to see that you were not completely satisfied with your purchase. We would like the opportunity to gather some additional information an...

Worked quickly
Would RecommendI bought this as an alternative to a kill trap. Followed directions and used peanut butter inside, and about one hour later, I heard a click and inside was a mouse. I honestly didn't think it would work but it did! Definitely recommend!
Mouse Trap
Would Not RecommendThis device did not catch any mice but it may be that the mice retreated from the cats. I wish I could have rated it based on my comment but "does not apply" is not available...
We are sorry to see that you were not completely satisfied with your purchase. If a rodent is not caught within 2-3 days we recommend moving the trap...


We're sorry to read about your disappointment with Tomcat Live Catch Single-Catch Mouse Trap and appreciate your feedback. If is not closed but b...