Ratings may include incentivized customer reviews.
What Customers Are Saying
The product is a simple and effective mouse trap that has received mixed reviews. Many customers report it successfully catching mice, praising its ease of use. However, some have experienced issues with the trap's spring strength and bait being taken without triggering the trap. Overall, it seems to be a reliable and affordable option for dealing with mouse problems when used correctly, though it may not be perfect.
Customer review summary generated by AI, including incentivized reviews.Very disappointing
Would Not RecommendI've had the wooden Tomcat traps for about a year and they are always set. After several months I noticed that the staples that hold the spring assembly to the base began to work there way out of the wood. The base seems like balsa wood, not even pine so doesn't hold well. I have had to epoxy the staples in in order to continue using the trap. Not inexpensive but cheap!
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
Mouse aren't fooled by plastic cheese
Would Not RecommendMice can't see the plastic cheese in the dark. Mice are attracted by smell. The plastic hook is not sharp enough to attach bait. The mice can steal the bait without getting caught. The old fashioned mouse traps with the metal bait hook work much better.
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
We are sorry to hear of the issues you've had with your Tomcat Wooden Mouse Traps. Some mice are much smarter than we give them credit for. For this r...
Would buy again.
Would RecommendI purchased a four pack of these with the Tomcat attractant gel. I set them where I had signs of mice. I only thought I had one but in less than 24 hours I had caught two.
Feeding only
Would Not RecommendI set the four trips out filled him with peanut butter next day the traps did not go off and all the peanut butter was gone
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
We apologize for the issues you've encountered with your Tomcat Mouse Wooden Traps. We are not sure why the traps did not go off for you. Some mice ar...
No weak spring here
Would RecommendThe Tomcat mouse traps I bought at my local Lowe’s store were highly effective. Trapped four of the little rodents in my garage during a two week period. Used a dab of peanut butter on each one. They, in my opinion, died instantly. The springs were so strong it nearly severed the head on impact! Great product and very effective.
Can't set the traps
Bought four of these and only one will set. Not a good product.
Weak Spring
Would Not RecommendFirst, my neighbor abandoned their house, the lawn is 4 foot tall weeds and who knows what was left inside. So needless to say, I have a serious mouse problem. They enter the basement and somehow make their way into my heated house, plus I feed my dog inside. The traps seem to work okay for me, they catch the mice, BUT do not have enough force to kill them. They are, however, a little harder to set because the plastic trigger is heavier, especially with bait. But once you figure it out, they ar...
FANTASTIC PRODUCT
Would RecommendSo I was fed up with this mouse creeping in my apartment every night so I decided to take action. Being a college student, I needed something cheap and effective. Well, this product was the perfect solution. I put some peanut butter on the trap and at night it went off and I killed that pesky mouse. The setting of the trap was easy for the most part. Also, the plastic may seem cheap, but it works just as well as the metal traps. All the negative reviews on this product are definitely from user e...
Great if you want to fees the mice
Would Not RecommendI purchased 3 packs (12 traps) and set them all throughout the garage. The next morning, the traps were licked clean of the peanut butter and not a single trap had been triggered. We used a small amount of bait and set the traps perpendicular to the walls as recommended. So either we have ninja mice who hovered above the traps mission impossible style or these traps don't work. (Seriously, I tried to trigger the traps after the fact using a wooden skewer and was able to press the pressure pad un...
One out of four doesn't cut it
Would Not RecommendI set this trap four times with peanut butter. Result: one kill and three times the mice stole the peanut butter without setting off the trap. The mechanism simply is not sensitive enough.
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
We do apologize for the traps not giving you the expected performance. We are not sure why the trap is not being triggered, although some mice are sma...
Horror Show
Would Not RecommendIt shouldn't be this complicated. I don't know if something has changed at the factory with the manufacturing process, but these springs are NOT strong enough. Two of the last three mice caught with these traps have not died, and instead have crawled all around, clamped right behind the head, struggling to survive. If your idea of a fun night is hearing a loved one scream because instead of being humane and killing the mouse, the manufacturer decides to get all "Jigsaw" and create an elaborat...
Easy to Use
Would RecommendPurchased these for our garage. Easy to bait, simple to use, and cheap enough to throw away when you catch one.
Works well in basement
Would Recommend[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Easy to set, fast acting, mouse was not able to clean trap
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
Mouse diner
Would Not RecommendI may as well run a mouse diner with these traps. They clean their plates and not set off this trap. Tried the sensitivity setting to the right, to the left and even pushed the trap trigger down to where I am almost tripping it myself. No luck with these at all. They lick it clean. On a positive note, they aren't expensive. I think I'll try the glue traps next.
Get the Mouse !!
Would RecommendGood old fashioned trap.. use a very small amount of peanut butter, raw bacon works too ... place the trap along the edge of a wall , they run along edges .. careful the trigger is sensative
Couldn't find victor medal pedal ones at the store
Would Not RecommendTried these instead, caught one FAT mouse but other than that the bait is getting taken without getting set off. I don't know why they think they can improve on the one with a metal bait holder because they haven't do it yet. The victor ones go off on even scrawny little mice and I'm going to have to go to the competitor's bright safety colored store and get a few 4 packs for two twenty seven...
Useless because poor manufacuring
Would Not RecommendJust another frustrating poorly manufactured product. The tolerances are off so bad that only about half the traps in a package can actually be set once baited. The other half simply aren't positioned correctly to allow for enough tension to keep the trap loaded and it'll snap back on you before you can ever get it placed. Normally that'd be frustrating but when dealing with a mouse trap it is a good way to break a finger. I'm just so frustrated with these cheaply made products that are so poorl...
Old school traps work the best
[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Finally had chance to test product. These original design wood traps work great. I don't think that anyone has built a better mouse trap.
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
Worst mousetrap that I have ever purchased
Would Not RecommendI"ve used countless mouse traps over the years because of the field mice that want to winter over in our house. The Tom Cat mouse trap is hands down the worst Ive ever purchased. You can't set it without it springing closed before it can be put in place. I also almost broke my finger a few times thanks to the premature release. I know how to set a mouse trap and have never had problems like this one. Put plainly, its garbage, their quality control is horible. They're cheap but for a reason, it d...
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
We are sorry to hear that you have been so disappointed with the Tomcat Wooden Mouse Traps. Generally, the traps are very reliable. We want you to b...
Not as well built as older ones
Would Recommend[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] These wooden traps are not as well made as ones I have from 20 years ago.
From ScottsMiracle-Gro

We are sorry to hear of your dissatisfaction with Tomcat Wooden Mouse Traps. The traps are meant to be reusable, but not for an indefinite amount of t...