Ratings may include incentivized customer reviews.
What Customers Are Saying
The product has experienced a significant decline in quality and consistency. The signature crunchy cake coating is often missing or severely reduced, leaving the bars with little texture or flavor. The ice cream itself has also changed, with the creamy vanilla layer frequently missing and the strawberry flavor tasting artificial or overpowering. Customers report finding foreign objects in the bars. There are widespread complaints about inconsistent quality, with some boxes containing properly coated bars while others are completely bare. Overall, the consensus is that the product is a shadow of its former self, and many loyal customers say they will no longer purchase it in its current state.
Customer review summary generated by AI, including incentivized reviews.Very Disappointing 😞
Would Not RecommendThis is definitely false advertising. The ice cream bars look nothing like pictured. I purchased them for the coating. I can buy a half gallon of strawberry swirled vanilla ice cream for the same price if I only wanted ice cream.
From goodhumor.com
The changes they made are Disappointing
Would Not RecommendThese used to be my favorite ice cream bars but everything about them has changed. First the ice cream color is a bright unnatural red. It used to be a pale pink color with red in the middle. It tastes sour now and has no strawberry or vanilla taste. The outside coating is no longer completely covered and is severely lacking in the cake or shortbread taste. It doesn't actually have much flavor. It makes me so sad. I won't be buying these anymore. It does not taste good. Bring back the original b...
From goodhumor.com
Doesn’t taste how it used to HUGE quality drop.
Would Not RecommendI loved these as a kid and haven’t had one in years went and picked up a box at the store and they don’t taste how they used to and the cake part on the outside doesn’t even cover the entire bar. It is very disappointing because I remember these being really delicious, even my wife says they taste different and not in a good way.
From goodhumor.com
My childhood on a stick!
Mmmm.. it’s like my childhood memories on a stick! Just the right size for a creamy, crunchy strawberry delicious snack! Packaging is unmistakably Good Humor!
From influenster.com
Strawberry Shortcake Bar
This is favorite and this box doesn't taste right. I am disappointed. I kept chewing, it tasted rubbery instead of edible.The stick was short, I couldn't even hold it.
From goodhumor.com
False advertising
Would Not RecommendThis is definitely not in good humor what so ever.imthought I had got a bad batch but it looks like they are charging the same price if not more than before but they’re giving us less?
From goodhumor.com
Where are the crumbs?
Would Not RecommendThese have always been my favorite, but recently they all look like this! Genetic brands are starting to be better quality at this point
From goodhumor.com
Disappointed
No cake crumbs, it tasted like frozen milk. :( used to be my favorite childhood sweet treat!
From goodhumor.com
No cake crumbs
Would Not RecommendVery disappointed with my purchase. This is a childhood favorite of mine and there was absolutely no crumb coating on the popsicle, also tasted slightly freezer burned. Very expensive treat for what was packaged.
From goodhumor.com
We’re sorry to hear this, the quality of our products is important to us. We’d like to gather more details about the product and your experience. Plea...
Marriage
Would RecommendIdk what ice cream everyone’s getting but I’ve got a ton of cake pieces, I’m in love with this ice cream, I mgoing to marry this ice cream,
From goodhumor.com
Awful!! Don’t buy!!
Awful! I get robbed buying a six pack of your bars.. and NONE of them had the coating on them! Consumers work hard for their money to enjoy the little things in life. This is no longer one of those things
From goodhumor.com
Where are the crumbs??
Would Not RecommendBought a box and was so excited. I haven't had them in a while and they are a nostalgic treat for me. Where are the crumbs??? They used to be covered in them but the one I opened had five little crumbs. It looked like a pink popsicle. So disappointed.
From goodhumor.com
We're sorry to hear that you were disappointed with our Strawberry Shortcake Bar. Your feedback helps us improve. Please contact our Consumer Services...
Worst buy
Would Not RecommendHalf of the icecream was missing. Such a waste of money.
From goodhumor.com
Disappointed
Would Not RecommendI bought these as I love them; however this time there was no cake coating.
From goodhumor.com
Please do not waste your money!!
Would Not RecommendUsed to love this ice cream. I got it all the time. Purchased it a couple days ago and the ice cream is barely in there it's mainly this weird tasting sherbet. The shortcake crumble doesn't takes like cake crumbles at all. It tasted like coconut was in the crumble. It's not good at all and I will definitely not be buying again.
From goodhumor.com
Disappointed
Would Not RecommendThese are usually my favorite ice cream, however the last two boxes we bought have huge, gaping wholes of the coating. There has hardly been any on all of the bars. Very disappointing
From goodhumor.com
Good product
Would RecommendEveryone in my family love this product! Can’t keep enough in the freezer.
From goodhumor.com
No Coating
Would Not RecommendEvery single bar in the box barely had any coating on them, very disappointed!
From goodhumor.com
No cake coating anymore!
I love these things since I’ve been a kid but I’ve bought six boxes of these in a row and they have 20% of the cake coating on the exterior of the bar. I don’t know what’s going on but they used to be completely covered with the coding now there’s maybe five granules on there is this a cost, saving measure, good humor?
From goodhumor.com
Thank you for sharing your experience with us. We're sorry to hear that you were disappointed with our Strawberry Shortcake Bar. Your feedback helps u...