Ratings may include incentivized customer reviews.
What Customers Are Saying
The product has experienced a significant decline in quality and consistency. The signature crunchy cake coating is often missing or severely reduced, leaving the bars with little texture or flavor. The ice cream itself has also changed, with the creamy vanilla layer frequently missing and the strawberry flavor tasting artificial or overpowering. Customers report finding foreign objects in the bars. There are widespread complaints about inconsistent quality, with some boxes containing properly coated bars while others are completely bare. Overall, the consensus is that the product is a shadow of its former self, and many loyal customers say they will no longer purchase it in its current state.
Customer review summary generated by AI, including incentivized reviews.I don’t know if the recipe has changed or what but I’ve gone through 3 boxes and all of them have sooo little crumbles on it I was confused. I love strawberry shortcake ice cream bars but goodness..things have changed. I want the old recipe back..or add more crumbles
From goodhumor.com
Salty
I love this popsicles I don’t like to write bad reviews but maybe it was a bad batch but as I bit one it tasted salty I made my boyfriend return it back to the store we purchase it sadly that was the only one
From goodhumor.com
Extra stick
Would Not RecommendSo when I was eating my ice cream I found a random stuck it is about half. This just turned me all the way off I love this ice cream but this was neglectful not making sure your products are ready to ship.
From goodhumor.com
ICE CREAM FAVORITES NO LONGER THE SAME
The biggest changes in ice-cream history are THE GOOD HUMOR STRAWBERRY SHORTCAKE ICE CREAM BAR & THE ORANGE CREAMSICKLE.... BOTH HAVE CHANGED UNTIL THEY ARE UNIDENTIFIABLE. .... THEY ARE HALF THE SIZE, THEY TASTE ARTIFICIAL AND LIKE PLASTIC... THEY ARE NOT THE SAME... AND I'M POSITIVE THE CORRUPT NEW OWNERS ..UNILEVER... ARE TO BLAME
From goodhumor.com
Wood/Stick in my ice cream bar
Would Not RecommendI opened up the ice cream bar and when I got the bar out I saw a piece of what looks like wood or the stick engraved into the ice cream. I could’ve choked on it if I didn’t see it. I have video proof and or pictures.
From goodhumor.com
Tasted like chemicals
My daughter just took one bite, spit it out and said it tastes bad. I tried it and I agreed. It tasted like chemicals. The other ones in this box tasted fine. For how much these cost, ALL OF THEM should be edible. Do better.
From goodhumor.com
Not what I ordered.
Would Not RecommendThere's no vanilla ice cream in them. I bought two boxes and I'm disappointed. It's just the strawberry ice cream. Ewww. First it was the coating mishap now this. What is going on at the factory.
From goodhumor.com
Disappointing
Would Not RecommendMany of them didnt have the coating. Disappointed since that is my favorite part.
From goodhumor.com
A yummy sweet treat
My favorite dessert will always be ice cream and these brand of ice cream are one of my favorites. My top favorite are the chocolate eclair but these are still really good!
From influenster.com
Childhood on a stick!
A nostalgic taste of my childhood! Used to get these from the ice cream truck and they still taste the same. The ice cream is firm and the outside crumbles are delicious, when frozen they're cold, not sticky and last a while before starting to melt.
From influenster.com
BEST STRAWBERRY SHORTCAME ICECREAM OUT THEREREEE LIKE GUYS NO OTHER STARWBERRY SHORTCAKE ICECREAM CAN CONPARE TO THIS ONE
From goodhumor.com
Delightful
One of my favorite ice cream bars. I love them.Especially on the summer time but also I can eat them 24/7. They are always affordable I normally get like 2 boxes at a time
From influenster.com
Acid taste
I love these, however when I opened my ice cream, it tasted like acid or some type of chemical. Now, I am afraid to even try them again.
From goodhumor.com
Budget cut backs?!
Would Not RecommendMaybe I picked up a bad batch or they’ve done budget set backs but my entire bar had no cream in it. It was completely the strawberry (red) ice cream with a little amount of crumb coating. They really used to be a great ice cream and I hope they fix this problem.
From goodhumor.com
NOSTALGIC AND YUMMY
Would Recommendso nostalgic. My boyfriend says the toasted almond were better but these are my favorite
From goodhumor.com
Buyer beware
My shortcake bar barely had a stick to hold on to. The flavors in my box varied with some barely having any strawberry flavor at all. I am very disappointed and will not buy anymore.
From goodhumor.com
Faulty
Ive had 3 so far and all three barely have a popsicle stick to hold on to and the one the stick wasn't even on it
From goodhumor.com
Don’t miss out on this classic strawberry treat
This is such a classic treat! I’ve loved good humor’s strawberry shortcake bar since I was a kid. Whether you eat it bite by bite from the top down, or eat off the cake coating first and then divulge into the middle part that’s bursting with strawberry flavor, there’s no wrong way to enjoy it!! If you like strawberries and ice cream, you’ll love this.
From influenster.com
Terrible
Would Not RecommendWhat happened to these?! The vanilla ice cream is non existent, and the cake coating is about 10 crumbs on the outside. We were excited about purchasing one of our classic faves turned into a huge disappointment.
From goodhumor.com
Delicious flavor.
Love the taste of this ice-cream! Delicious for a cheap ice-cream bar! Love how the crumbles taste. This is a childhood classic ice cream bar and a great portion size
From influenster.com