Ratings & Reviews for Good Humor Strawberry Shortcake Ice Cream 3-oz

What happened?!

This used to be my favorite dessert. I am in my 50s and had been eating these since I was a kid. I just got a box and they are now extremely disappointing. They have a bland almost chemical fake taste to them now. I had to check the box to make sure I didn't buy some sort of generic brand. These are awful now. Unless they go back to their old recipe, I'll never purchase these again.

Poor quality

These used to be amazing they were large and both and an even amount strawberry and vanilla frozen dessert I hadn't bought them in a few years and then bought 2 boxes last week and there was almost no vanilla just a tiny bit on the bottom and it seems like its a recurring thing very sad and a big let down

Very small

These are so much smaller, less for more $$, won't be purchasing aagain.

Very, Very Awesome bar!

Very great! I just wish that the wrappers in the grocery store version is simple for no reason and its just white, I kinda want it to be like the one from the ice cream truck. Just red and bright! I love the bar! I have NO Idea what these people talking abt wit these sticks in em.

Its so delicious

It's so delicious, sweet, tastes like real strawberries,I like the portion package super delicious, my kids love this ice cream, it's pretty sure the best idea for kids

Something changed and not for the better

The Strawberry Shortcake Bar used to be my favorite, but they changed the recipe or something, and now the strawberry taste has disappeared. It tastes like nothing, just some sort of sugary cream. So disappointing.

Yum

it is yummy and i like to eat it because it is sweet and yummy

Huge Disappointment

I was surprised to find this in my local supermarket! It had been my all-time favorite and I looked forward to enjoying them again. I purchased it today and just had one. There is no ice cream in this bar at all. It seems to be nothing but flavored and colored ice. I took a few bites, realized that this product is nothing like the treat that I so enjoyed and which is shown in the packaging. I threw it and the rest of the 6 bar package into the trash.

The recipe changed for the worse

I knew immediately when the recipe changed because of the added coconut to the bars. It’s made it hard to enjoy now because after the ice cream and cake crumble goes down, I’m left with inedible paper like coconut flakes that I have to keep spitting out. Are you all losing money and had to add that as a filler to the cake crumble? And there’s no vanilla ice cream as the picture shows either. This is sad and disappointing because I loved this ice cream bar. Please go back to the original recipe i...

A little issue but not awful

Not use to this brand but I thought these had more of a "crunchy bits" outer layer? Still delicious of course! just wish it had more yummy crunchy stuff. :)

What. In. The. World?!

Wildly different from what I remembered. The quality is horrible now. I am confident ill never buy another good humor bar. Store brands are better quality than this now.

Quality and Taste extremely lacking

I’ve been enjoying these for over 40 years, and this is the first time I’ve been genuinely disappointed enough to write a negative review. Every bar in the box looked like this—nothing like what they’re supposed to be. The coating was uneven and sparse, and the overall appearance was clearly off. This wasn’t a one-off issue; the entire box was the same. More concerning, the ice cream itself had almost no flavor. It was bland and didn’t resemble the product I’ve come to expect from Good Humor. ...

Wood in ice cream

I had an inch chard of wood in my bar. Im very lucky I didn't get hurt. Ill never buy from you again.

I bought a 6 pack of the bars and there was pieces of wood in the one I ate. They didn't come from the stick on the one I ate.

WHERE IS THE CRUMBLE

WHAT IS GOING ON WITH THE QUALITY CONTROL TEAM FOR THESE ICE CREAM BARS???? These have gone so downhill. Half of the bars barely include any of the shortcake crumble on the outside. The last box I got the crumble was like dust instead of chunks. I loved these so much but I’m going to have to stop buying them with how hit or miss they are - 90% they’re a miss now due to the production team

Bad experience

It barely has any strawberry shortcake coating on it it’s very like and tasted like yogurt

False Advertisement, Off taste and Cake Crunchless

I purchased these, wanting the flavor that I always loved and not only does it taste different that it usually does, its something different, like coconut or something, maybe. But the bar was basically a white vanilla ice cream bar with strawberry inside based on the amount of cake crunch that was on it. I can literally count them easily, thats how sparse the cake crunch is and from reading other comments I see that this is common. Where is the quality control? Does Good Humor not care about th...

Is it just me or are these bars getting smaller?

Is it just me or are these bars choosing more, but getting smaller..? I wish I could figure out how to post picture of the bar I just opened because it's literally a quarter of the size of the package it was in! That's very disappointing when you're craving these and there only one left in the box.

Stop advertising the white creamy center

Theres no white creamy center hoesssssssssssssssssss

What’s going on

Barely any crumb coating and found a stick on my ice cream bar.