Ratings may include incentivized customer reviews.
What Customers Are Saying
The garden soil provides mixed results. Some customers report it is a good, affordable option that helps plants thrive, while others describe it as more like mulch or wood chips that does not hold moisture well or support healthy growth. The quality and performance appear inconsistent, so customers should inspect the soil before purchase and be prepared to amend it if needed.
Customer review summary generated by AI, including incentivized reviews.mostly mulch with a little bit of dirt
Would Not RecommendI had bought a few bags for my raised garden beds and all the bags I opened up was just mulch and bits of plastic in it. All the plants I have in my bed aren't growing. Total waste of money.
Garden Dirt
Would RecommendI mix it with Peat and compost in my garden. It has a lot of chunked up wood in the dirt.
From Garden Soil 2 Cubic feet Vegetable and flower Garden soil Verified Purchaser
Fugus mushroom
Would Not RecommendPurchased on May 2023 and used for two vegetable gardens. One garden looks okay although seedlings don't seem to grow well. The other vegetable garden also looked okay BUT there are white mushrooms and fugus growing.
Wet but good dirt
Would RecommendWet, I soaked through. So, it was heavy to tote but it seems to be good dirt for the garden.
From Garden Soil 2 Cubic feet Vegetable and flower Garden soil Verified Purchaser
As expected
From Garden Soil 2 Cubic feet Vegetable and flower Garden soil Verified Purchaser
I WAS WRONG!!!!! GREAT SOIL HOLY COW
Would RecommendI made a smartallec review about how this stuff should be sold as lumber cause its all mulched wood. guys, i spent twice as much on the other hjalf of my soil, and now that im nearing june, the soil that i complained about, has plants THRIVING, and WAY ahead of everybody around here.... however the plants in the expensive soil, are struggling a lot! i have yrs of growing under my belt, and im having serious issues with yellowing leaves, and the typical causes are not there... this soil is WONDER...
Garden Soil
Would Not RecommendTo many sticks and tree bark, very little soil....
From Garden Soil 2 Cubic feet Vegetable and flower Garden soil Verified Purchaser
Thank you for your review. We are so sorry you had a bad experience with our product. Oldcastle strives to provide the best possible products and c...
Mulch
It’s more mulch than soil.
Thank you for your review. We are so sorry you had a bad experience with our product. Oldcastle strives to provide the best possible products and c...
Thank you for your review. We are so sorry you had a bad experience with our product. Oldcastle strives to provide the best possible products and c...