Ratings may include incentivized customer reviews.
What Customers Are Saying
Customers overwhelmingly praise this mulch for its fine, triple-shredded texture, natural black appearance, and soil-enriching properties. Many highlight how it spreads easily, enhances flower colors, retains moisture, and breaks down into nutrient-rich soil over time. However, a growing number report recent quality decline, receiving bags filled with large wood chunks, rocks, and dirt instead of fine mulch. Despite these inconsistencies, most customers remain loyal, valuing its premium feel and long-term garden benefits.
Customer review summary generated by AI, including incentivized reviews.I only use this brand of mulch
Would RecommendAlways quality.
Verified Purchaser
Brown Black Forest Mulch
Would Not RecommendI have used this product for the past 5 years. It has always been black. This year it a dark brown, not black. I don't want to change my color scheme in my garden. So I am no longer going to use this product.
Verified Purchaser
Excellent product for the money
Would RecommendFine chopped mulch. Good for potted plants.
Verified Purchaser
Excellent Quality Mulch That Looks Better and Last
Would RecommendI decided to spend a little extra on ProLine Black Forest Mulch, and I'm glad I did. The triple-shredded texture gives it a much more uniform and finished appearance than many of the cheaper mulch brands. It spreads easily, stays in place better, and doesn't contain the large wood chunks that often end up scattered in the lawn. So far, the color has held up well and looks much richer than the bargain mulch often sold for around $2 per bag during Memorial Day sales. Those cheaper products tend t...
Verified Purchaser
Nothing
Would RecommendNice, fine-textured mulch.
Verified Purchaser
Great mulch
Would RecommendI have used this mulch for years and love it. It breaks down nice by the end of the year so I don't need to pull it out because its faded or has big chunks in it like the dyed mulch.
Verified Purchaser
Mulch
Would RecommendThis seems to be the most popular mulch in our area. Lowes is always running out. Grab several bags while it was in stock and we'll use it around the flower beds and other locations. Seems to work great for the season and then breaks down over the fall and winter to become part of the soil.
Verified Purchaser
Compliments on how this looks
Would RecommendGreat fine mulch that protects, moisturizes and looks great all season long
Verified Purchaser
Perfectly shredded
Would RecommendLove how finely this mulch is shredded. Rarely any big chunks. Looks beautiful. I do wish the bag was a little bigger.
Verified Purchaser
Black Forest mulch - for the discerning gardener
Would RecommendThis is the best mulch I have ever used. Looks great and is a consistent fine grind quality.
Verified Purchaser
Not ideal for mulching to keep down weed growth!
Would RecommendMulch is very small, fine pieces. Great for tidy flower beds, not great to keep weeds down.
Verified Purchaser
Choice natural mulch
Would RecommendNo dye and breaks down over the course of a season to enhance soil.
Verified Purchaser
easy to apply
Would Recommendcolor
Verified Purchaser
Great organic mulch!
Would RecommendI am glad that Lowes carries the Black Forest Mulch! It is an organic triple-processed hardwood mulch that brings so many benefits the perennial plants and trees where it is applied. It is a great product for a good price that I am happy to use for my clients or at home.
Verified Purchaser
Helps to amend the soil as well as moisture.
Easy to spread and does not have huge clumps of wood..
Verified Purchaser
Rocks and white dust
I’ve been buying this mulch for years and it used to be great but the batch this may 2026 has a ton of smashed white rock in it and I have to cover it all with new mulch.
Very fine grounded mulch
Great looking mulch
Verified Purchaser