
Ratings & Reviews for Southwire Smart box 1 -Gang Polycarbonate Old work Round Electrical Box
Ratings may include incentivized customer reviews.
What Customers Are Saying
Customers are divided on this product. Many praise the innovative all-in-one design for creating precise 2.5-inch drywall openings without separate tools, calling it a time-saver for light fixtures and retrofitting. However, a substantial number report the plastic cutting teeth melt, wear down, or fail to penetrate drywall, forcing manual finishing. Installation requires a specific 9/16" nut driver, and compatibility is limited to smooth, new drywall. While some value the convenience concept, durability concerns and the cost premium over standard alternatives lead many to recommend against purchase.
Customer review summary generated by AI, including incentivized reviews.Easy installation
Would RecommendEasy installation, worked exactly as expected.
From Smart box 1 -Gang Polycarbonate Old work Round Electrical Box Verified Purchaser
Works just like it should
Would RecommendEasy installation
From Smart box 1 -Gang Polycarbonate Old work Round Electrical Box Verified Purchaser
Works great.
Would RecommendIt would be nice if they listed the size of the nut driver that you need for your drill. All of mine were too small. Once I got it in, it worked great. I ended up drilling it in by hand with a racheting socket set. I didn't feel like making an extra trip to the store.
From Smart box 1 -Gang Polycarbonate Old work Round Electrical Box Verified Purchaser
Great Concept, Poor Execution!
Would Not RecommendGreat concept, but poor execution! Self-cutting design with integral locking mechanism looked like an elegant answer to a common wiring issue. However, the teeth quickly wore down to nubs after barely penetrating the paint on my sheetrock. Also, the pointed hole starting nib is much longer than the distance between sheetrock surfaces on standard 2x4 framing and likely to penetrate the opposing wall surface. Finally, the hexagonal drive receiver inside the box appears ready to accept a drill-driv...
From Smart box 1 -Gang Polycarbonate Old work Round Electrical Box Verified Purchaser
Southwire does it again!
Would RecommendLove everything Southwire makes and this product is no different. It makes for a really installation with those teeth but doesn’t tear things up. The plastic is durable, not brittle at all like some products.
worked once, second time not so much
Would RecommendI used this box to add a ceiling fixture in a bedroom. Worked great, it saved me from buying a hole cutter. Bought a second to use in another room, but the teeth wore down before I got 1/8 inch into the sheet rock. I had to finish the hole with a saw.
Thank you for leaving your review. We're sorry to hear about your experience with our product, and this isn't what we would expect to hear. S...
fast and easy! worth the few extra dollars,
Great idea -- needs improvement
Would Not RecommendSouthwire has come up with a great innovation for installing a round box in existing drywall -- a box with teeth. The idea is to use the box to drill through the drywall since it has detachable cutting teeth. Once the hole is drilled, discard the teeth and wings on the box flip out to grip the drywall. That part works excellent. However, even following the instructions to angle the box during cutting, if you go slow, the teeth "melt" or wear away before cutting all the way through. So a fiv...
From Smart box 1 -Gang Polycarbonate Old work Round Electrical Box Verified Purchaser
Hello, and thank you for your review. Your feedback is very important to us, and we will be sure to share your comments with our team for future impr...
It will not cut through a lightly textured ceiling
Would Not RecommendThe teeth burnt off before I went through the drywal. I had to cut it with a hand saw anyway.
From Smart box 1 -Gang Polycarbonate Old work Round Electrical Box Verified Purchaser
Thank you for leaving your review. We're sorry to hear about your experience with our product, and this isn't what we would expect to hear. S...
Hold-Screws Not Included
Would RecommendThe device hold screws weren't included. Spend $10 on this thing, and they won't even through in the screws. The smoke detector came with screws but they didn't fit. BTW, it takes 4mm x 10mm screws.
Thank you for taking the time to leave your review, as feedback like yours is what helps us to always be sure that we are providing the best products...
Marks but doesn't cut.
Would Not RecommendDid not last long enough to go through drywall. The marked area wasn't big enough for the outlet after I cut it with another saw.
From Smart box 1 -Gang Polycarbonate Old work Round Electrical Box Verified Purchaser
This isn't what we would expect to hear about any of our products, and we want to see how we can make this right. Please reach out to us at consu...
This is a fantastic product and saved $$ by not having to purchase a hole saw. Worked perfectly in cutting through the sheet rock and solidly secured it to the wall.
made install easy!
Would Not RecommendInstalled two in about 5 minutes. super easy. use a drill on low speed, driver was too powerful. Will definitely use again.
Smart design
Would RecommendVery good design for old work.
From Smart box 1 -Gang Polycarbonate Old work Round Electrical Box Verified Purchaser
Hole saw teeth promptly melted
Would Not RecommendCut a shallow groove before the hole saw teeth promptly melted. Finished with a knife. I wanted to like this product, but not worth the extra money.
This isn't what we would expect to hear about any of our products, and we want to see how we can make this right. Please reach out to us at consu...
Hole saw on electrical box melted
Terrible product, the cutting blade melted before it cut the hole for the box.the box worked good.
From Smart box 1 -Gang Polycarbonate Old work Round Electrical Box Verified Purchaser
This isn't what we would expect to hear about any of our products, and we want to see how we can make this right. Please reach out to us at consu...
Dislike/ junk
The part the drill attached to broke before it got throught the sheet rock The teeth wore out at they attempted to cut the sheetrock.
From Smart box 1 -Gang Polycarbonate Old work Round Electrical Box Verified Purchaser
This isn't what we would expect to hear about any of our products, and we want to see how we can make this right. Please reach out to us at consu...
Great for older homes
Would RecommendWorked great for the plaster ceilings of my 1951 house
From Smart box 1 -Gang Polycarbonate Old work Round Electrical Box Verified Purchaser
This isn't what we would expect to hear about any of our products, and we want to see how we can make this right. Please reach out to us at consu...