Ratings may include incentivized customer reviews.
What Customers Are Saying
Customers overwhelmingly praise the replacement flap for its perfect fit and quick installation, typically completed in under five minutes. Reviewers consistently note the flap restores pet independence, eliminates drafts, and prevents bugs from entering. The material's flexibility allows pets to pass through effortlessly, and many customers report replacing flaps multiple times over years of reliable use. A small number mention the flap feels thinner than older versions or occasionally fell off due to mounting issues. Some wish for separate replacement magnets or brackets. Despite minor concerns, most customers consider it a durable, cost-effective solution that extends pet door life significantly.
Customer review summary generated by AI, including incentivized reviews.Best Replacement Flap
Would RecommendWell-made and was easy to install. Fits perfectly.
From PetSafe
Replaced damaged, worn, doggie door flap.
Would RecommendUnscrewed the mounting screws, cleaned all surfaces. Installed new flap ensuring not to strip out the mounting screws with my power drill. deposited the old one in the trash an washed up.
From PetSafe
Wouldn’t buy again
It’s ok. Wish it hung straight down without a bow in it
From PetSafe
Perfect
Would RecommendFits perfect. Like new. Just as described in the website.
From PetSafe
PERFECTAMUNDO !
Would RecommendIt is exactly the perfect replacement from the original flap that came with the original sliding door insert .. I could not be MORE PLEASED.. m
From PetSafe
Features
Flap does not seal very well as had small gaps on sides. Too easy for dogs to grab and chew on as magnet strip is only at the bottom, as mine did and destroyed.
From PetSafe
Thankful for Replacement
Would RecommendMy dogs tear through the dog door and after a few years there is only about half a flap. So grateful I don't have to replace the entire door when only the flap is worn.
From PetSafe
Extreme
Would Not RecommendI bought the LG. Extreme dog door w/3 flaps.all two flaps wouldnt hang right from start. Let lots of air by. The magnet was weak. A few months after installing the corners were shot and more air comes in.I have small wild animals come in if the discover it. I continued using it because my money is so tight. And on top of that I can't find a 3 flap replacement kit.
From PetSafe
We're sorry to see that your flaps have been damaged! Though we regrettably cannot troubleshoot issues that occurred before the flaps were damaged, th...
100% terrific product
I bought my door 13 to 15 yrs ago. I am just now replacing the flap. I’m in northern Ohio hot to frigid. In that time I have had 5 50 plus lb. dogs (4 labs 1 Aussie) and 15 plus kitties and one pigmy goat who stuck his head through regularly. The goat and dogs were too large for the door!! The used it anyway. The Aussie still uses it leaving fur on ALL SIDES as she squeezes her ample girth through the medium size opening. She’s a big 67 pound girl and a 14 years old I’m not going to punish he...
From PetSafe
We really appreciate you taking the time to share this review, Lori! It's wonderful to hear this door has been such a helpful, long lasting fit for yo...
Perfect fit
Would RecommendPerfect fit. Kind of hard to install. Best if two people work together.
From PetSafe
Worked perfectly. I really couldn’t be happier
Would RecommendBeautiful door. Worked flawlessly and easy to install
From PetSafe
Thank you for your feedback, we're sorry to hear about these issues you've run into! We would love to help find a solution to this, If you would like ...