Ratings may include incentivized customer reviews.
What Customers Are Saying
The Cuisinart 2-Slice Metal Classic Toaster offers a mix of features and performance. It has an attractive design with easy-to-use controls, and can handle a variety of breads and bagels. However, some users report issues with uneven toasting, where one side comes out much darker than the other. The toasting dial is also described as being too loose, making it difficult to achieve consistent browning. While the toaster has versatile settings and a convenient crumb tray, some customers feel it lacks the high quality expected from the brand.
Customer review summary generated by AI, including incentivized reviews.Cuisnart 2 slice toaster
Would RecommendWe have used the toaster for several weeks and it works great. Good size for our countertop. Recommend it.
From cuisinart.com
Great Toaster!
Would RecommendI’m really enjoying my new Cuisinart toaster! It toastes evenly and very easy to set it to the darkness/lightness that I want. It looks very nice sitting on my counter and matches my other appliances.
From cuisinart.com
Buy it!
Would RecommendGood toaster, toasts fast without drying out the bread.
From cuisinart.com
Standard toaster
Would RecommendStandart toaster. Toasts bread like it was made for. Nothing fancy.
From cuisinart.com
Uneven
Would Not RecommendWe had an old Black & Decker toaster that conked out on us, and thought we would kick it up a notch with the stainless steel Cuisinart. Sadly, it doesn’t toast very quickly, and more importantly, not evenly at all.
From cuisinart.com
2 slice metal classic toaster
I had an older model of this toaster and it lasted for years. So I decided to get a new one
From cuisinart.com
Toasts quite well
Would RecommendI'm glad we purchased this toaster, though I wish the selector dial felt more firm, and landed right where you want it to land. It's a bit soft, but you just have to watch where it is. Hard to know exactly what # to choose, but we're finding out what # NOT to choose. I toasted frozen waffles, chose the frozen button, and the bottom half of the waffle was really dark, the top much less so. It's a learning curve, I guess. But it has nice heft to it and cord is a good length. Overall, we're pleased...
From cuisinart.com
Toasting to Perfection.
Would RecommendExcellent toaster which toasts quickly and perfectly. Love the different setting options. Top quality toaster from an excellent manufacturer. And, at a great price! Great value for money!!!
From cuisinart.com
Not the best Popper-Upper
Disappointed in the "pop-up" feature, as the toast does not energetically pop up after toasting. Quite often have to use tongs to get the toast out or you have to hold up the plunger manually.
From cuisinart.com
Thank you for your feedback—we’re sorry to hear the pop-up feature isn’t performing as expected. Sometimes the mechanism can become slightly misaligne...
Widow perfect size !
Would RecommendI had a 4 Cuisinart 4 slice toaster which I loved but since I am a widow I decided to down size to this 2 slice toaster . Perfect for me and I think it looks nice.
From cuisinart.com

Thank you for sharing your experience with us—we’re sorry to hear the toaster isn’t heating as quickly as expected and is producing uneven results com...