Ratings may include incentivized customer reviews.
What Customers Are Saying
The product has received mixed reviews. Some customers found it to be an effective and easy-to-use trap that successfully captured rats, while others reported significant issues with the product's quality and design. The trap's simple setup, sturdy construction, and ability to effectively capture rodents were praised by many. However, a large number of customers complained that the trap broke or became unusable after limited use, and that it was not sensitive enough to reliably trigger. Concerns were also raised about the trap's potential to cause unnecessary suffering for trapped animals.
Customer review summary generated by AI, including incentivized reviews.Couldn’t even set it
Would Not RecommendI couldn’t even set this trap. It would click but not catch. Since it is just plastic, you can’t even bend the catch into place to fix it.
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
Convenient and safe setting......very important..!
Would RecommendI have had a stressful problem with packrat(s) getting into my car's engine compartment and chewing up the wires. Twice this caused big financial damage to me. I've been using some scent deterrents and even some strobe lights, but only with partial success. I think once these rats have laid down a "scent trail" in your engine compartment, they'll continue to return night after night because their own scent provides that comfort zone, and thus confidence. I was at a loss as to what to do until so...
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
useless
Would Not Recommendive been dealing with a rat problem for way to long now, and ive tried just about every trap out there besides electric traps. i picked up this one, thinking maybe just maybe it would do the trick. my current rat was able to get away from this trap without a scratch. i dont know if he was just smart and never touched the trigger, but it was able to get the treat also placed in the trap without setting it off. i tried many times putting it in different places and using different things to attract...
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
We apologize for the difficulty you experience with Tomcat Secure-Kill Rat Trap. As the product manufacturer, we are very interested in supplying cons... Read More
They don’t fly apart when the trap is set!
Would RecommendUse these for overpopulation of ground squirrels. Work great. The Victor brand trap completely breaks when set off. Tomcat can be used over and over!
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
Single use - not useful
Would Not RecommendRat was able to avoid getting trapped. Was / am very frustrated that parts are designed to break and make it impossible to reset and try again. Avoid this product
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
We are sorry to hear of your experience with Tomcat Secure-Kill Rat Trap. As the product manufacturer, we are very interested in supplying consumers w... Read More
U dirty rat
Would RecommendSaw a healthy mouse in the house, purchased the rat trap. Baited with some chocolate & peanut butter and less than 24!hours problem solved.
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
Didn't work to well
Would RecommendI bought this product a couple weeks ago. Well this morning I heard it pop something shreaked. I waited 20 minutes to get up whole trap is gone.
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
That Rat is Done like Dinner!
Would RecommendGot him on the first night! I have read that it is best to avoid handling or touching traps with bare hands. Always wear gloves when handling because of the scent from human oil might scare or spook the rodent. I have noticed a huge improvement in the effectiveness of traps over the years by NOT handling or touching traps with bare hands EVER.
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
Failed to kill
Would Not RecommendI bought two of these rat trap yesterday and set it to kill the rats in our backyard. The bait was good bacon. In the morning next day both baits were eaten, both traps was off and no dead rats in it. I followed all instructions, it was correctly set but it failed.
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
We hate to hear that Tomcat Secure Kill Rat Trap did not take care of your issue. We want you to contact us so that we can extend to you our guarantee... Read More
I used this trap, and the rat ate the food, then escaped!
I used this trap, and the rat ate the food, then escaped!
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
We are saddened to hear that you experience trouble with Tomcat Secure Kill Rat Trap. We ask that you contact us so that we can help with this. We can... Read More
Cheap plastic breaks making the trap unusable!
I am very disappointed with this product! 3 of the 5 traps I bought just failed after a couple of weeks. The plastic parts that the spring attaches to just breaks away and the trap becomes useless. This is clearly a design flaw and my hardware store guys just shrug and say we just sell them. Do not make the mistake of buying the Tomcat Secure - Kill Rat trap
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
We are sorry to hear of your experience with the Tomcat Secure-Kill Rat Trap. This trap is not designed to be used more than once, and may not work af... Read More
This was one tough rat...WAS.
After my neighbors moved and took their wonderful mouser cats with them, my dogs were picking up an unwelcome scent in the garden. I got the Tomcat trap to avoid pinching my fingers, and it was very user friendly. I set it up out of the dogs’ reach with peanut butter and one piece of dog food. It snapped on the second night, and caught the large rat by only one paw, but caught it! He was still alive though. I went to the garage to get a shovel. By the time I returned, he had escaped the trap, bu...
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
Will not snap
Would Not RecommendThis trap will not snap closed on a rat. Five times now they have eaten the peanut butter off of it and it never went off. This last time they covered it in dirt and rocks because it didn't get more peanut butter on it last night.
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
We would be interested in speaking with you further about this so that we can learn why our Tomcat Secure Kill Rat Trap may not have worked. We are n... Read More
Actually works
Would RecommendWe have had trouble with desert woodrats in our part of Nevada. We caught some with live traps but there was one we could not catch. He ate my flowers and plants on our deck and moved under our house. We tried the old fashioned wood and wire rat traps but he took the bait, set off the traps and got away. Then I saw your traps online and we figured we would try them. We were desperate! Used peanut butter with a couple of raisins stuck in it in the bait cup and put it on the deck when it started t...
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
They ate my produce...that meant war!
Would RecommendMy neighbors yards are overgrown and have become a haven for rodents. I have a nice garden, including vegetables and fruit trees. I also have two 10 pound dogs who would have loved to reign death on the vermin, but they wouldn't come into the yard when challenged to fight. My older pup has experience killing vermin and has even taken down a young skunk. The rats would instead taunt the dogs from the overhead power lines, which didn't go over well. Lots of barking and frustration. One large Norwe...
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
Hear click but does NOT catch, trap will not set
Would Not RecommendWe bought two of the Secure Kill rat traps six weeks apart at different locations of the same home improvement store (in different nearby cities). Neither Secure Kill trap would set. We tried setting it by hand and by foot and neither way worked. We could hear it click but it would NOT engage. We thought it was an unlucky fluke when the first one didn't work, but then when we finally had the time to go buy another one, it didn't work either. What are the odds??? Then we went to a different major...
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
We apologize for the inconvenience that Tomcat Secure Kill Rat Trap has caused. .Please take a moment to contact us about this. We are more than happy... Read More
Simple and Safe
Would RecommendThis product is the best that I've ever used it's simple and the bait bowl is just the greatest ! I bought the Tomcat - Rat Snap Trap it got my good friend within 30 minutes and he or she is now in Rat Heaven ! Yes Sir, Peanut Butter and a small piece of dog food in the center of the peanut butter did the trick !
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
Repeat customer, highly satisfied!
Would RecommendWe live near a creek, which tends to cause seasonal influxes of new rats around our property. As described by others, setting these traps is a VERY simple process, not to mention the easy disposal and reset of the trap. I usually end up leaving them outside along fence paths and around the perimeter of our house, regularly checking them in peak season. The only issue I have is that our Texas heat and weather can quickly deteriorate the plastic and metal parts. Quite often the single point of fai...
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
BEST. TRAP. EVER!!
Would RecommendWe had a super genius rat that we were unable to catch with sticky paper or conventional snap traps for almost a week. It would always be able to get the bait and get away, twice even springing the snap trap. This amazing trap caught it on the first night!!
From ScottsMiracle-Gro
This is by far the best trap ever!!
Would Recommend[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] We had a rat in our house for about 3 weeks, Out landlord brought us the wouldn't trap but the rat manage to eat the peanut butter and get away... So to after I got off work I went to Orcher supplies and found a very unique trap, I also bought Stickie traps to. I left my house, and when I walk back in a couple mins later I herd the trap snap and rat died trap is very powerful and I would referred to a friend to buy.
From ScottsMiracle-Gro

We are sorry that you had difficulties with Tomcat Secure Kill Rat Trap. Place the trap on a leveled surface and set it with the foot or the hand. Ple... Read More