Ratings may include incentivized customer reviews.
What Customers Are Saying
Customers overwhelmingly praise the delightful fusion of creamy peanut butter, crunchy Oreo pieces, and white chocolate, celebrating the satisfying texture contrast and nostalgic flavor profile. Many describe each bite as sweet, salty, and crunchy all at once, calling it a "dream come true." The white chocolate layer complements the peanut butter and adds a smooth finish. Some note the Oreo flavor is subtle, and a few find the treat very sweet or prefer less white chocolate. Despite minor critiques, most customers enthusiastically endorse the product and plan to repurchase.
Customer review summary generated by AI, including incentivized reviews.Great contrast of flavors
This new product is an absolute delight. Each bite gives the perfect crunch from the crisp Oreo pieces tucked inside a smooth, creamy peanut butter center. The white chocolate topper ties everything together. If you love Reese’s and Oreos, this mash up is for you.
From influenster.com
Yum!!!
Delicious! Love the combo with Oreo. I do feel that the peanut butter overpowers the Oreo cookie crunch. Otherwise I love it, it’s so good. The white chocolate on top is wonderful. Great treat after meals or when I have a sweet tooth craving.
From influenster.com
The Reese's Oreo Peanut Butter Cup
is honestly my all-time favorite candy. And let me tell you, I love candy! These still have the classic Reese's creamy peanut butter texture with added crunchy oreo pieces. If you love Reese's and Oreo, please give these a try.
From influenster.com
Reese’s Oreo Chocolate!
8/10 Reese’s has a white chocolate top, milk chocolate bottom and a Reese’s paste and Oreo centre. It is nice and crunchy. The Oreo’s do get a little lost within the Reese’s paste, but there is a good portion size of Oreo’s which give a nice crunch. Only 100 calories per cup.
From influenster.com
I like both separate not so much together
These are honestly not too bad. Would be better with less white on top. They are half chocolate half white with peanut butter and the oreo cookie pieces inside. I saw them and love both individually. Id give these a 6/10. Id eat them if they were there but im not sure if i would purchase them in the future.
From influenster.com
GLUTEN-FREE!!! AMAZING!!!!
First, these taste just like girl scout tag-a-longs which my girls can't have anymore because they have celiac's. THEN I heard these are GLUTEN-FREE!!! These are AMAZING!!!! My girls are so excited they can eat them and they truly taste absolutely delicious! We were so happy to see them in the shareable size now too! I wish they were offered at more stores (I only find them at target). Please do not discontinue!! And thank you for making them gluten-free!!!
From hersheyland.com
Yum
I am a huge fan of reeses , they are my favorite chocolate so I was super excited when I heard they had an oreo version . They are super yummy, they dont really taste like oreo but are still enjoyable . They are sweet and have that reeses flavor with something special.
From influenster.com
SOOOOO GOOD!
[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] The packaging is really cute, taking the best of Oreo & Reese's. Additionally, there's a picture of the product on the front. It is the perfect balance of sweet & salty with the perfect amount of peanut butter. They were very fresh & creamy. Absolutely awesome!
From hersheyland.com
🥜🍫
Reese's Oreos King Size Peanut Butter Cups take indulgence to the next level. The classic Reese's peanut butter is perfectly blended with crunchy Oreo cookie pieces and coated in smooth milk chocolate. Every bite is rich, sweet, and packed with texture. It's a must-have for fans of both Reese's and Oreos looking for a truly decadent treat.
From influenster.com
Odd one out.
I'm going to admit that I'm the odd one out: I don't care for the original Reese's peanut butter cups. I've tried the other variations: with Reese's Pieces, with pretzel, caramel, chocolate fudge, etc... They're ok. BUT THESE? These are magical. I made a post to my Facebook page because everybody knows, or they should by now, I don't like Reese's peanut butter cups. I let my friends and family know that they absolutely HAD to try these because they're magical. They're tastier than I ...
From hersheyland.com
coming from an avid reese's fan
these are fireee!! i am a huge reese's fan typically the original ones. i picked these up at the store the other day to try and omg they're amazing. just the right amount of everything. love the creamy peanut butter with the crunchy oreo pieces. definitely gotta try this if you haven't !
From influenster.com
Mmmm good
Melt in your mouth goodness. Just enough crunch to accompany the smooth peanut butter and chocolate. A bit on the very sweet side. Not evenly distributed throughout cup.
From influenster.com
NEVER GET RID OF THESE!
I absolutely love this! I will be devastated if they ever stop selling this! I buy them by the box in fear I won't be able to find them anymore! I love to put them in my ice cream, and blend them in milkshakes! SOOOO GOOD! Currently at work with one on my desk, and my co-worker is begging for one of my cups! I don't want to share, I don't even like to share these with my kids! Tbh, I hardly like her, but I guess I will do a good deed and allow her to try it. However, I don't know if she really h...
From hersheyland.com
The Reese's Oreo cup is delicious and delivers on what it promises
These Reese's Oreo peanut butter cups really do shine. You can taste all the elements such such as the white chocolate, and milk chocolate together with the peanut butter and cookie crumbs in the center bringing it together. The cookie crumbs offer a little crunchwhich really elevates the reeses cup.
From influenster.com
Yum
[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I absolutely loved these Reese’s Oreo cups! What a brilliant idea from them to combine these two flavors together! They were super delicious and a yummy treat!
From hersheyland.com
Really good!
The Reese's x Oreo duo is really good! I love the texture and taste of the cookie and peanut butter! The white chocolate and milk chocolate is also a nice combo. The aroma still smells like peanut butter so that hasn't changed. Overall this is pretty solid and I'd definitely get it again but try it refrigerated!
From influenster.com
Cheap excuse for a Reese's cup
A long time Reese lover that usually has a snack size bag in one sitting(while watching a movie) so I decided to purchase one of the Reese's/Oreo cups King Size packages today. I have to say this is the WORST TASTING Reese's I have ever had in my 45+ years......and that's including the terrible pb&j limited cups or the Elvis experiment back in the 2000's. These are way too sweet, very little peanut butter and the cookie part is like ground-up burnt brownies 🤢
From hersheyland.com
AMAZING
these are actually the most perfect candy-I always pefer white chocolate candy,but its normally too sweet. WELL THESE ARE HALF WHITE CHOCOLATE AND HALF MILK CHOCOLATE SO THEY'RE THE PERFECT AMOUNT OF SWEET. May I also add- its the perfect amount of crunchy and perfect amount of peanut butter. I was completely cured of my depression after eating these, and I didn't even know I was depressed in the first place! PLEASE DON'T DISCONTINUE THESE EVER I'LL CRY MYSELF TO SLEEP EVERY NIGHT. ❤️❤️
From hersheyland.com
Reese's OREO Peanut Butter Cups
Both Oreo and Reese's are my favorites so I was thrilled when I heard about this... Unfortunately it's just not for me. It's in no way bad or anything, It's just kinda blah. I just don't think the two chocolates pair well together. The Reese's overpowers the Oreo so much you can hardly taste the Oreo. On the plus size the Oreo does make it more crunchy. It's about half and half texture wise. Oh and the cups are both Milk and white chocolate which I didn't even realize until halfway through. It's...
From influenster.com
Sweet treat
[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] A sweet treat from Reese's. These Oreo peanut butter cups are definitely more crunchy. But I don't taste strong oreo flavor and definitely very sweet, too much for my liking. But rating it 3 stars for good 'cause if you're Reese's fan, you'll probably like these.
From hersheyland.com