Ratings may include incentivized customer reviews.
What Customers Are Saying
Customers overwhelmingly praise the delightful fusion of creamy peanut butter, crunchy Oreo pieces, and white chocolate, celebrating the satisfying texture contrast and nostalgic flavor profile. Many describe each bite as sweet, salty, and crunchy all at once, calling it a "dream come true." The white chocolate layer complements the peanut butter and adds a smooth finish. Some note the Oreo flavor is subtle, and a few find the treat very sweet or prefer less white chocolate. Despite minor critiques, most customers enthusiastically endorse the product and plan to repurchase.
Customer review summary generated by AI, including incentivized reviews.Sweet tooth
These are so good! The Oreo filling on top pairs nicely with the peanut butter. I like these better than regular peanut butter cups. Highly recommend
From influenster.com
Keep the items seperate
Two of my favorite things.. resees and Oreos. The quality of the product is great however the taste didn’t mesh well in my opinion. I wasn’t able to finish.
From influenster.com
Perfect amount of sweetness in each bite
Such a great treat after a hard day of work. They just melt in your mouth and the consistency is perfect. Great job on the packaging which really draws in the customer eye.
From influenster.com
Delicious!
Would RecommendIt tickles my gluten free guts that the Oreos in this little sweet treat are gluten free, because that means I can enjoy them safely, and man are they good! I hope they become part of the permanent lineup!
From hersheyland.com
Oreo peanut butter mash up
I was very excited to try these Reese's peanut butter cup and Oreo mash up. I love the classic peanut butter cups and Oreos so I thought I'd love these! I love the peanut butter flavor however I really didn't notice the Oreo flavor. The cups were somewhat crunchy from the cookies though. Overall, these were very tasty but I will just get the regular peanut butter cups instead.
From influenster.com
Perfectly balanced PB cups
I just tried the new Reese’s Oreo peanut butter cups and I have to say, they were pretty good. There is nice balance of white chocolate, milk chocolate, peanut butter and Oreos to get be it a nice crunch. The one thing I would change to make it better, would be a layer of Oreos or more oreos to add to the crunch factor. All in all I like the Reese’s Oreo peanut butter cups and I will purchase them again.
From influenster.com
Sweet and savory
It’s sweet and savory, the Oreos gives it a nice crunch. You can smell and taste the peanut butter even with the other flavors. The white chocolate is a little bit too sweet but overall this snack is good.
From influenster.com
Didn’t hit the mark
I really wanted to love this product. I mean Oreo, peanut butter and chocolate…how could you go wrong? The first one was ok but by the 2nd one I could really start to taste the aftertaste. One or two is fine but after more than that, you can really pick up on the aftertaste
From influenster.com
It’s such a rich chocolate and its Oreo flavor is delicious
It is the richest chocolate with its peanut butter and its oreo flavor is so rich it is not so sweet you can enjoy it with a glass of milk. I love it and everyone enjoys my house
From influenster.com
Perfect combination in one!
The Reese’s Oreo cups are the perfect mix of sweet and salty. When you first take a bite, your tastebuds are met with sweetness of the Oreo flavor then are immediately rushed with the subtle saltiness of the peanut butter. This is also a great pick for those who enjoy different textures while snacking. The bits of Oreo give it a great crunch as the rest of the cup melts in your mouth. Overall, a good choice if you’re looking for something different!
From influenster.com
Perfect Combo!
This is a definately a keeper! Very good. Ratios are perfect!
From hersheyland.com
Sweet snack!
This Reese's Oreo candy bar is very sweet. It has a crunchy bite. It smells fresh. It is packaged nicely. One bar is a good serving size. It leaves a sweet aftertaste in your mouth.
From influenster.com
Perfect balance
I’m a big fan of Oreos and Reese’s so this snack called my name in the checkout line. I wasn’t too sure about the result prior to biting but I was blown away. It was the perfect balance of sweet chocolate, crunchy cookie, and salty peanut butter. The pack didn’t even make it out of the parking lot. I love even consistency and it didn’t fall apart while eating.
From influenster.com
Super yummy goodness!
Yummy! Melt in your mouth goodness molded into a peanut butter cup is just madness. The taste all wrap together and even have a good texture of creamy and a bit of crunch for the oreos. I love the packaging as well, they stood out so you knew they werent just regular.
From influenster.com
Great Treat!!
[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] 1000% recommend the peanut butter cups as a treat!! The addition of the Oreo ingredient added the perfect little crunch and saltiness to smoothness of the peanut butter and chocolate! These were the perfect size for a mid day snack!
From hersheyland.com
Reese's Oreo King Size Cups
I was excited to try this combination between two of my favorite snacks, but was not a major fan. While the pieces of Oreo provide a nice crunch, the peanut butter flavor overpowers the rest. The white chocolate on top also adds an extra level of sweetness but does not taste like Oreos (besides the cookie chunks, I'm not sure what else was supposed to be considered Oreo-related). From someone with a major sweet tooth, I found it to be too sweet overall and could not finish a cup in one sitting. ...
From influenster.com
HSY_FTE_Testing
Good. Yummy yummy in my tummy, testing to see what happens next.
From hersheyland.com
A great mix
Not to sweet and has a great crunch too it definitely one of my favorites
From hersheyland.com
Amazing!
This is literally so good. Stop and shop was giving samples and I took one, figure you can’t really improve on a classic like Reese but you totally can, this Oreo pb is so good! It’s crunchy and it’s so so so good.
From influenster.com