Ratings may include incentivized customer reviews.
What Customers Are Saying
Customers overwhelmingly praise the perfect balance of creamy peanut butter and smooth chocolate, describing the combination as flawless with ideal texture and rich flavor. Many love the holiday-shaped varieties, finding them tastier and more enjoyable than traditional cups. The snack-sized portions appeal to reviewers for convenient indulgence and portion control, with consistent freshness noted across purchases. A small number report the taste has changed, citing artificial chocolate flavor, though these concerns are vastly outweighed by enthusiastic positive feedback. Overall, most consider this a beloved, timeless treat worth repurchasing.
Customer review summary generated by AI, including incentivized reviews.So good
Reese anything is incredible!! But peanut butter pumpkins just hit the spot especially during the fall. More peanut butter flavor than the typical peanut butter cup. I love them!
From influenster.com
Cute and yummy
These reeds cups are so cute , the size is perfect now to big not to small. Perfect amount of peanut butter and chocolate. Great for snacking . Love they do this with every season.
From influenster.com
Yummmm!
My favorite Reese’s. I swear they fill these with more peanut butter filling than regular Reese’s. It’s the perfect ratio but we all know the peanut butter is the best part of a Reese’s anyway! I love when these come out around Halloween.
From influenster.com
Love theseee
If you don’t love these, I’m ASHAMED. I love these so much. They’re so much better than the normal Reese’s but I’m also a fall/halloween girly. It’s great in shape and size.
From influenster.com
Liked the original recipe better
This used to be my favorite Halloween candy. I still enjoy them but they changed them in some way. They don’t taste quite the same. I don’t know if these were a part of the recipe change but I look forward to them going back to the original recipe. The chocolate has more of a carob taste now and the peanut butter tastes less peanuty and more like straight sugar. The portion size is perfect and always has been but they need to fix the recipe.
From influenster.com
Good size and good chocolate balance
I loved the taste and packaging I personally prefer the original but this is a good second and no stale taste the bag lasted me a good time for amount given I loved the size aswell wasn’t to small
From influenster.com
Ooey gooey melt in your mouth goodness 😍
Honestly, who doesn't love spooky and reeses combined? Crazy people that's who! 🤣 lol I love all things reeses and halloween so these are right up my alley for splurging on 😜 They are the perfect combo of spooky, peanut butter, and milk chocolate! 10/10 reccomend 🥰
From influenster.com
Useful calories when you're starving
Love the peanut butter flavor. It smells appetizing. Could have leas sugar though. The packaging size is good. I sometimes buy in bulk and keep a stash by my office desk. Every time I get too hungry, I just reach for a pack.
From influenster.com
Always in the house...treat!
I just bought a bag and there's only one left in the drawer! My husband and daughter love the flavor of these and the individual wrapping keeps them fresh! There is not aftertaste and we are good with the ingredients to be able to share with our kids.
From influenster.com
The best Halloween candy you’ll ever have!
My absolute favorite! They taste amazing the peanut butter and chocolate combo is everything! They taste like a regular Reese but more of everything! The aftertaste is delicious.
From influenster.com
Sweet, creamy and totally addictive of peanut butter chocolate
God!! We are officially obsessed with this chocolate. Yummm!! My son tries to put the whole piece of chocolate in his mouth at once. 😄 he always ask me for more and more!!
From influenster.com
They Are Delicious
Reese's Peanut Butter Cups are the perfect mix in for almost any dessert. The rich milk chocolate and sweet/salty peanut butter is just delicious. I like to make banana bread with mine! It smells amazing!
From influenster.com
Right amount of chocolate to peanut butter
These are delicious! The right amount of chocolate to peanut butter! They look like pumpkins. For some reason the shapes always taste better and this did not disappoint!
From influenster.com
Perfect Halloween twist on Reese’s
Fun twist on the traditional Reese’s. The chocolate shell with creamy peanut butter inside leaves you feeling satisfied and happy. The chocolate shell texture is almost smoother than the traditional Reese’s and delicious. The individual portions are great so they stay fresh and you can limit portions.
From influenster.com
Taste amazing!
I love all Reese’s but specifically love the shaped ones. I feel like the pumpkin have more peanut butter than a normal Reese’s peanut butter cup and I love it.
From influenster.com
Special for any occasion
I love this I could eat it daily, its flavor and creamy texture I love that consistency in the mouth with shape you bite it leaves your mouth so sweet, it is special for any occasion whether it is a date with your children or couple the perfect gift for someone who loves the creamy, I love its function in my life I would buy it again and again, without getting tired of saying that it is delicious.
From influenster.com
Yummy pumpkin
Just like your average Reese’s cup expect This one I find Has more peanut butter that the original one. Plus, there slightly bigger then a average one.
From influenster.com
Spooooky Chocolate
Unsure if the ingredients have changed within the last year, but these now have somewhat of a gritty feeling (think protein powder) and the aftertaste is almost as if they were old/expired. I’m a big fan of Reese’s, but when I purchased the pumpkins for Halloween, they were off. The appearance is still the same and aesthetically pleasing for Halloween. They do still have the good, chocolate melt as usual. I’m hoping I may have just purchased a bad batch and will try again next year!
From influenster.com