Ratings may include incentivized customer reviews.
What Customers Are Saying
Customers overwhelmingly praise the perfect balance of creamy peanut butter and smooth chocolate, describing the combination as flawless with ideal texture and rich flavor. Many love the holiday-shaped varieties, finding them tastier and more enjoyable than traditional cups. The snack-sized portions appeal to reviewers for convenient indulgence and portion control, with consistent freshness noted across purchases. A small number report the taste has changed, citing artificial chocolate flavor, though these concerns are vastly outweighed by enthusiastic positive feedback. Overall, most consider this a beloved, timeless treat worth repurchasing.
Customer review summary generated by AI, including incentivized reviews.Tasty
Easily the best Reese’s ever. They have stuffed full with peanut butter and are the perfect size. They are a seasonal favorite in my household. I buy them every year
From influenster.com
The Ultimate Seasonal Treat!
The combination of creamy peanut butter and milk chocolate is simply iconic. Unlike the standard cups, the pumpkin shape has a much more generous amount of peanut butter, which makes every bite incredibly satisfying. As soon as you open the packaging, you are greeted by that unmistakable sweet and roasted scent of peanut that makes your mouth water.
From influenster.com
Wives favorite around Halloween
These are my wives absolute favorites. She claims they have better chocolate to peanut butter filling ratio. Fun shape and always great taste!
From influenster.com
Unpleasant chocolate combination
I don’t like these chocolates at all because the type of chocolate is a little greasy and I don’t like the combination with peanut butter at all, but if you like peanut butter this can be for you.
From influenster.com
Just so good 🍫🥜
Just so good! The flavor is great the size is great the value is great. Nothing like a good pumpkin. The fun size ones are amazing and honestly Halloween gold if I do say so myself!
From influenster.com
My kiddos favorite treat!
I cannot eat these as I’m allergic to peanuts BUT this is a treat my kiddos love! The holiday treats always “taste better” according to them! Since it’s chocolate they make a slight melt mess BUT it’s worth it to know my babies are happy :)
From influenster.com
The best REECE’S product!
The packaging perfectly matches the product and gives all the right vibes. It has the ideal balance of chocolate and peanut butter, creating an indulgent flavor that tastes amazing. The rich aroma of chocolate blended with creamy peanut butter makes it even more irresistible.
From influenster.com
If your allergric
I absolutely loved the Reese’s Milk Chocolate Pumpkin! The peanut butter chocolate ratio is perfect, making it extra creamy and rich. It melts in your mouth.
From influenster.com
Rich, creamy and smooth
Became a fan with just one bite. It’s perfectly creamy and it melts quickly in the mouth. It’s not too sweet, the peanut butter balances it well..
From influenster.com
So good
Reese anything is incredible!! But peanut butter pumpkins just hit the spot especially during the fall. More peanut butter flavor than the typical peanut butter cup. I love them!
From influenster.com
Cute and yummy
These reeds cups are so cute , the size is perfect now to big not to small. Perfect amount of peanut butter and chocolate. Great for snacking . Love they do this with every season.
From influenster.com
Yummmm!
My favorite Reese’s. I swear they fill these with more peanut butter filling than regular Reese’s. It’s the perfect ratio but we all know the peanut butter is the best part of a Reese’s anyway! I love when these come out around Halloween.
From influenster.com
Love theseee
If you don’t love these, I’m ASHAMED. I love these so much. They’re so much better than the normal Reese’s but I’m also a fall/halloween girly. It’s great in shape and size.
From influenster.com
Liked the original recipe better
This used to be my favorite Halloween candy. I still enjoy them but they changed them in some way. They don’t taste quite the same. I don’t know if these were a part of the recipe change but I look forward to them going back to the original recipe. The chocolate has more of a carob taste now and the peanut butter tastes less peanuty and more like straight sugar. The portion size is perfect and always has been but they need to fix the recipe.
From influenster.com
Good size and good chocolate balance
I loved the taste and packaging I personally prefer the original but this is a good second and no stale taste the bag lasted me a good time for amount given I loved the size aswell wasn’t to small
From influenster.com
Ooey gooey melt in your mouth goodness 😍
Honestly, who doesn't love spooky and reeses combined? Crazy people that's who! 🤣 lol I love all things reeses and halloween so these are right up my alley for splurging on 😜 They are the perfect combo of spooky, peanut butter, and milk chocolate! 10/10 reccomend 🥰
From influenster.com
Useful calories when you're starving
Love the peanut butter flavor. It smells appetizing. Could have leas sugar though. The packaging size is good. I sometimes buy in bulk and keep a stash by my office desk. Every time I get too hungry, I just reach for a pack.
From influenster.com
The best Halloween candy you’ll ever have!
My absolute favorite! They taste amazing the peanut butter and chocolate combo is everything! They taste like a regular Reese but more of everything! The aftertaste is delicious.
From influenster.com