Ratings may include incentivized customer reviews.
What Customers Are Saying
The product features a nostalgic design with mixed reviews. Many customers express disappointment over the replacement of the gumball eyes with chocolate, describing it as a negative change that detracts from the iconic experience. Some also note changes to the overall flavor and texture, with the new version tasting worse. However, there are still loyal fans who continue to enjoy the product as a beloved childhood treat, though some struggle to find it in stores. The overall consensus is that the original gumball-eyed version was superior.
Customer review summary generated by AI, including incentivized reviews.It’s good but why did you get rid of the gumball eyes they looked way better with the gumballs
From popsicle.com
No
Would Not Recommend[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] These popsicles were so good….in 2015. The old gumball eyes were my favourite part!! I grew up on these, once I found out they switched the eyes to chocolate, I removed myself from being a loyal customer. I heard some people say they were a choking hazard? So are the popsicle sticks. At least just put an age limit. It should be up to the parents to decide if their kids can eat these yet. Or at least remove the eyes for them! There are so many o...
From popsicle.com
The eyes bring tears to my eyes
Would Not RecommendChocolate doesn’t go with the flavors. The eyes make no sense and taste terrible. If not glorious gum balls that at least a different flavor candy melt.
From popsicle.com
Love these
Would RecommendMy whole family love these please can I get some for free
From popsicle.com
Mixed feelings
Would Not RecommendLook I live this popsicle but they took out the bubble gum eye balls and I’m extremely upset about it I’ve been buy it since I can remember. I definitely don’t like the chocolate eyes
From popsicle.com
My son enjoys
My son loves these! Has had many of them and ask for them over and over.
From popsicle.com
Great concept
Its a family favorite and well enjoyed over the years including the cartoon series!
From popsicle.com
AFTER 20 YEARS...SUPER DISAPPOINTED
My brother and I have been eating these specific spongebob popsicles for the more than 20 years we've been alive. Recently bought some for old times sake and my number one issue is NO MORE BUBBLEGUM EYEBALLS. Why would you get rid of the most popular part of the popsicle?!?! My second is the chocolate! Who on planet Earth thought chocolate goes good with fruit punch flavored ice cream. It's outrageous. My third and final complaint PUT MORE OF THE COTTON CANDY FLAVOR IN THEM!
From popsicle.com
Cute
My favorite ice cream... fruit punch!! And the cotton candy also
From popsicle.com
Very Nostalgic!
This popsicle reminds me so much of the popsicles that are at ice cream trucks. This gave me a nostalgic vibe of the ice cream trucks. It also had a strong cherry taste to it.
From influenster.com
Why No More Gumball Eyes?
My absolute favorite!! Expect the gumball eye balls is what made it even better. What happen to them?
From popsicle.com
A Hit with the Grandkids
Grandkids love spongebob and this tasty, flavorful ice cream! And it's affordable! Doesn't melt quickly, thank god, so they're not a sticky mess.
From influenster.com
Great Taste
From popsicle.com
BRING BACK GUMBALLS
I want the gum balls back !! why’d did they ever change anyway 💔 this new chocolate flavor is gross
From popsicle.com
I really love your SpongeBob popsicles but I have stopped eating them because they reaplaced the gumballs for chocolate chips,BRING BACK THE GUMBALLS!!!!!
From popsicle.com
great but..
idk why they added chochote eye balls it was good when it was eyeless or when it was gumball but it does give nostalgia.
From popsicle.com
Absolutely horrendous
I am DEVESTSTED . Who knew a company could break someone's heart like this. Popsicle you should be ashamed! I always loved running up to the ice cream truck and getting my favorite popsicle, spongebob. My absolute favorite part was saving his delicious gumball eyes for last. The flavor may not have lasted long , but those crunchy eyes gave me a purpose. Imagine my surprise when I opened my popsicle to see, a fraud. This is not my spongebob popsicle. Who in their crazy mind puts chocolate chips i...
From popsicle.com
Won’t be eating these no more!
It barely taste like cotton candy it taste abit sour now… also what happened to the size of the bar? Y’all shrunk it down to half the size???
From popsicle.com
Change
Please put the gumballs back… the popsicle doesn’t taste good with chocolate
From popsicle.com
Nostalgia
Okay I have absolutely loved the sponge bob popsicles since as young as I can remember although just here recently I had purchased one and realized the popsicle no longer has the gum ball eyes instead it has been replaced with chocolate this makes me so sad because I remember them having ice cream and gum and it always felt like a two for one deal as a kid so please please please bring the gum ball eyes back 🙏🙏🙏🙏chocolate doesn’t belong with cotton candy or fruit punch flavoring
From popsicle.com
We truly appreciate you taking the time to share your feedback about our SpongeBob SquarePants™ Popsicles, and we're sad to hear you're not a fan. We'... Read More