Ratings may include incentivized customer reviews.
What Customers Are Saying
The product features a nostalgic design with mixed reviews. Many customers express disappointment over the replacement of the gumball eyes with chocolate, describing it as a negative change that detracts from the iconic experience. Some also note changes to the overall flavor and texture, with the new version tasting worse. However, there are still loyal fans who continue to enjoy the product as a beloved childhood treat, though some struggle to find it in stores. The overall consensus is that the original gumball-eyed version was superior.
Customer review summary generated by AI, including incentivized reviews.Why no gumball eyes???
Dear Popsicle, I want gumball eyes back. Can’t find perfect one with chocolate eyes. I want the gumball eyes back.
From popsicle.com
Loooooove them
Would RecommendI swear I’m obsessed with these pops I buy them in bulk now I can’t get enough of them 5 months hooked lol
From popsicle.com
These are so delicious, and I love the calorie content. These are hands-down, the best popsicles I like the Spider-Man one too. They should make a Dora one next.
From popsicle.com
Allergies
So upset about the change. As a person who gravitated to these popsicles and now I don’t eat them as I’m allergic to chocolate. It’s sad. Bring gum balls back.
From popsicle.com
Bring back the old one.
Would Not RecommendThe chocolate eyes and redesign are terrible. I've had these my entire life and I picked these up religiously whenever I could. I want the old one back
From popsicle.com
Putting chocolate on this should be illegal
Would Not RecommendChocolate completely ruins the flavor. Instead of enjoying gumballs I am picking off chocolate.
From popsicle.com
So Disappointed These are my favorite popsicles😔
Would RecommendI'm so mad that they go rid of the gumball eyes. These are my favorite popsicles of all time but its just not the same. I want those eyeballs back 😞
From popsicle.com
miss gumball eyes
Would Recommendwould be 5 stars but, I miss the gumball eyes. The chocolate eyes make the whole thing different. bring back the original one with gumball eyes please!!
From popsicle.com
Disappointed
I've loved these popsicles since I was a little girl, always looked forward to the ice cream truck coming around. Very disappointed in these now that they quit making them with the gumball eyeballs.
From popsicle.com
not so nice features
Would Recommend[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] i miss the gumballs really wish you guys sold that one as well
From popsicle.com
Summer with SpongeBob
My daughter’s favorite special treat. She is obsessed with Sponge Bob and thought that the popsicle was so fun to eat. The tart flavor and creamy texture was a perfect afternoon summer time treat!
From influenster.com
Same Pop? No - they skimped out
Gumball eyes were much better than the chocolate ones. Clear signs of corporate penny pinching. Not happy with popsicle execs.
From popsicle.com
New “improved” is disappointing.
I personally have loved these since I was a child. I recently purchased from a Wawa and was completely thrown off and disappointed by the change of the gumball eyeballs to the chocolate ones. The chocolate does not complement the popsicle at all.
From popsicle.com
Wheres the gum ball eyes
I used to get this ice cream when it had gumball eyes. I haven’t had it since they changed it, but come on why would you remove the gumball eyes and replace them with chocolate? Not cool. Take it back and fix it.
From popsicle.com
No gumballs eyes
Would Not RecommendNo gumballs, why would you get rid of the best part. Bring back the gumballs eyes
From popsicle.com
Gumball Eyes
[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Bring back the gumballs eyes please 12334566888434678875336678875
From popsicle.com
Horrible downgrade
It’s miles down from the glory that these once were. It was nostalgia you were selling, now…well
From popsicle.com
No more gum ball eyes.
Would RecommendYa'll removed the gum ball eyes and that is It's the only reason that I'm writing this bad report. Because usually I'll make great popsicles.
From popsicle.com
Small and mini,no gumball eyes.
Popsicles are good but changed really fast no more gumball eyes and just went completely mini and small I think it’s a waste of time to do all that for only a few people complaints I don’t recommend buying them for them to be smaller than my hand and on a big stick.
From popsicle.com
horrible
Would Not Recommendbecause the chocolate chips are bad.. they need to bring back the gum balls.
From popsicle.com
