Ratings may include incentivized customer reviews.
What Customers Are Saying
Customers overwhelmingly praise this compost and manure blend for significantly improving garden soil and boosting plant growth in vegetable gardens, flowerbeds, and raised beds. Most highlight its odorless nature and exceptional value for the price, with many using it annually as a soil amendment. However, some report inconsistent texture with rocks, sticks, sand, and clay present in bags. While a few find this frustrating, most accept these trade-offs given the affordability. Overall, reviewers consider it an effective, budget-friendly soil enhancer despite minor quality variability.
Customer review summary generated by AI, including incentivized reviews.Recommended
Great product and delivery!
Bang for your buck
Would RecommendGreat quality.
Great product for price
Would RecommendThis is a great mix. I used this to prepare all my flower beds!
Received wrong item
Would Not RecommendI ordered this compost and manure but received topsoil.
Rip Off
Would Not RecommendI was very disappointed! It’s true the product has no manure smell, but that’s probably because there’s almost no manure in it! It has less than a tenth of the nutrient concentration manure usually has, ( it’s on the label, but you have to look closely! ), and seems to be mostly wet sand. Not a great soil amendment or top dressing; humus or peat moss would be better. Lowe’s has another brand that costs a bit more, but at least has a nutrient analysis that’s in the right ball park!
Angel Thank you for your comment. This mixture consists of approximately 50% cow manure that has been composted for about a year. To enhance its qual... Read More
Items not delivered
Would Not RecommendMy items show they were delivered, but in fact, they were not delivered, and there is no picture showing a delivery
Rick Thank you for taking the time to leave a review, we value your feedback. Oldcastle strives to provide the best possible customer service and sup... Read More
Good value
Would RecommendExactly what we needed
Easy to spread
Would RecommendEasy to spread without problem.
Good Fertilizer
Would RecommendGood fertilizer. I mix it with regular soil when planting.
Decent product with occasional rocks
Would RecommendEvery bag I've purchased has had rocks or concrete pieces & a couple of those bags contained 3-4 very large rocks that measured 10 to 12 in in length
AHowery Thank you for your review. We are very sorry you found anything additional in your lawn and garden purchase. We have a very strict screenin... Read More
Quick Service
I had arrived and within 5 minutes or less the associate brought me my items.
Not like the compost we have bought in the past
Would Not RecommendFull of chunks of wood and debris
Thank you for your review. We are very sorry you found anything additional in your lawn and garden purchase. We have a very strict screening proces... Read More
Affordable
Would RecommendThe bag was not too heavy for me to handle. It enriches the soil in my flower beds. It is affordable.
It’s OK, I think
Would RecommendReally so far I’ve not been able to see the benefits from it however, I think it should be good. I’ve used it a few times. It’s a little expensive for poo but it’s kind of the way it is we all know that.
Seekms to help soil from hardening
Would Recommend
Thank you for taking the time to leave a review, we value your feedback. Oldcastle strives to provide the best possible customer service and support.... Read More