Ratings may include incentivized customer reviews.
What Customers Are Saying
Customers overwhelmingly praise this compost and manure blend for enriching soil and supporting healthy plant growth, particularly for vegetables, roses, and flowers. Many highlight its lack of odor, ease of use, and strong value proposition, with reviewers reporting excellent results when mixed with topsoil or used in raised beds and gardens. However, a notable subset consistently report rocks, sticks, clay, and sand mixed throughout, with some finding the texture too sandy or clay-heavy. Despite these debris concerns, most customers consider the performance and affordability worthwhile and recommend it for annual garden use.
Customer review summary generated by AI, including incentivized reviews.Garden life
Would RecommendAffordable and good soil
I like this soil, because it is better than what i have purchased from Lowes.
Terrible service
Would RecommendPerson supposed to be loading us stayed on his phone and we ended up having us load our own items
From Timberline 40-lbs. Organic Compost and manure Verified PurchaserVerified Pro
Good soil
Would RecommendGood soil for garden bed
A must for planting
Would RecommendIts a must i use this as fill when planting anything
Good topsoil
Would RecommendEasy to spread, not a lot of sticks mix in
All signs good
Would RecommendSo far so good. Bags didn’t rip and color looked really good. No giant chunks like I’ve had in other composts.
Cheap but good
Would RecommendI love it
Really good compost
Great compost when you cannot compost your own scraps or in my instance decide to start a garden prior to making a compost bin.
This is the one
Would RecommendGood Quality
Good value
Would RecommendGood product. Need more compost in ratio. Too much sand
Good for rhubarb
Would RecommendI always buy a bag of this compost for my rhubarb. It is good quality and the plants seem to like it.
From Timberline 40-lbs. Organic Compost and manure Verified Purchaser
FERTILZER
Would Recommendgood for starting veg, plants
Use this brand for best gardening results.
Would RecommendExcellent experience growing vegetables and flowers in backyard garden.
Got for clay soil
Would RecommendGood stuff. Just what my clay soil needed
Irritated Thank you for taking the time to leave a review, we value your feedback. Oldcastle strives to provide the best possible customer service an... Read More