Ratings & Reviews for Architectural Mailboxes Stanley Metal Extra Large Mailbox Black
Ratings may include incentivized customer reviews.
What Customers Are Saying
Customers overwhelmingly praise this mailbox for its large capacity, sturdy metal construction, and excellent value. Most highlight how the extra-large size easily accommodates packages, preventing items from being left unsecured. Reviewers consistently describe the build as durable with a quality paint finish, often contrasting it favorably with flimsier alternatives. Installation is noted as straightforward with included hardware. Many emphasize strong value, citing premium features at a competitive price. A few report minor issues like doors not staying fully closed or occasional water seepage, but these concerns are vastly outweighed by positive feedback. Overall, customers consider it a reliable, practical investment.
Customer review summary generated by AI, including incentivized reviews.Failed After Just 5 Weeks
Would Not RecommendI was initially impressed with this mailbox. It looked well made, felt sturdy, and installation was straightforward. Unfortunately, after only five weeks of normal residential use, the rivet holding the bottom-right door hinge completely broke off. The mailbox was never abused—it was only opened and closed gently a couple of times a day to retrieve mail. There’s no logical reason a hinge rivet should fail this quickly, which makes me question the quality of the hardware used. A mailbox is some...
Poor lid alignment
Would Not RecommendI purchased this product back in April and I didn’t install till July. When I went to install it the mailbox lid did not stayed shut. The inner lip the holds the lid close was riveted too low. I went back to store to get a replacement and Lowe’s stated it was past 90. It was 4 days after the 90 days of their poor customer service. I went to check on the same manufacturer mailbox in the shelf the they had same defect. Poor product and Lowe’s selling poor quality products.
Weak door attachment.
Mailbox door is attached to the box by one rivet on each side. Rivet hole enlarges over time as the door is opened & closed leading to door failure and no choice but to replace the box.
Great product
Would RecommendGreat size! My packages will nicely fit inside! I love the sturdiness of the metal. And it’s a plus that my magnetic cover will stick and make it pretty!
I like this mailbox and its size.
Verified Purchaser
It’s a mailbox
It’s a mailbox. Does everything it’s supposed to.
No hardware included
Would Not RecommendHow cheap and inconvenient not to include screws and nuts.