Ratings may include incentivized customer reviews.
What Customers Are Saying
Customers praise the product for easy installation on standard plastic mailboxes, often completing setup in under 10 minutes, and appreciate its affordability as a functional replacement. However, many criticize the all-plastic construction as flimsy, reporting that flag stems slip through housings and mounting plates warp, requiring improvisation with bolts and washers. Several note missing hardware despite being necessary for installation. A few find instructions unclear or feel the product doesn't justify its cost. Overall, most consider it adequate for basic replacement needs, though durability concerns limit satisfaction.
Customer review summary generated by AI, including incentivized reviews.Fits my Beautiful Mailbox Company perfectly
Would RecommendFits my Beautiful Mailbox Company perfectly - matching up with the holes in my mailbox. I had to add a washer, as the flag wobbled in the up position and did not lock well in the up position. Worked it out, but completes my paint spruce up of my mailbox - everyone says it looks brand new.
Verified Purchaser
Good price
Easy install
Verified Purchaser
Doesn't last long.
Would Not RecommendCheap material and bad design. Broke in two days.
Verified Purchaser
Old unusable mailbox flag hanging down replaced!
Would RecommendTerrible instructions for a newbie, but overall product great.
Verified Purchaser
This replaced a broken flag we had, looks great
Would RecommendVerified Purchaser
Great Experience
Would RecommendEasy shopping
Verified Purchaser
Don't waste your money.
Would Not RecommendPiece of junk. Had to drill 3 new holes. Plastic piece that was supposed to fit in the holes was cheap and didn't hold.
Verified Purchaser
None
Would RecommendIt is perfect for my needs
Verified Purchaser
It is what it is.
Would RecommendExact replacement for prior mailbox flag.
Verified Purchaser
Needs to be made in the USA
Would Not RecommendMade in China
Verified Purchaser
I'll do in a pinch.
Would RecommendWasn't just a one size fits all. Took a bit to make it work with my mailbox.
Verified Purchaser
does the job, but barely
Would Not RecommendFlimsy at best; it was the only choice available at the store. Would like a metal option or something more heavy duty. Seems to be barely holding on, and we just installed it last week.
Verified Purchaser
Poor Quality
Would Not RecommendCheap plastic, knobs to secure did not line up to my metal mailbox holes and template was destroyed when opening package. This was the only option available at Lowes, no metal flags.
Verified Purchaser
Deficient housing.
Would RecommendThe new flag is fine, but the square housing fails to hold the flag upright because its wider channel lets the flag's stem slide right past the catch. I re-used the old housing instead. The side-by-side photo, with the new one on the right, shows the difference in channel width. If you have to use the included case, you could try wrapping some tape around the stem to make it thicker.
Verified Purchaser
It serves its purpose.
Would RecommendIt fits perfectly on the mailbox
Verified Purchaser