Ratings may include incentivized customer reviews.
What Customers Are Saying
The product features a mix of positive and negative feedback. Many customers enjoyed the original design with gumball eyes, finding it appealing and nostalgic. However, the current version with chocolate eyes is widely seen as a downgrade, with customers feeling the new design detracts from the overall flavor and texture. Some express they will no longer purchase the product due to this change, though others emphasize the gumball eyes were the best part of the experience.
Customer review summary generated by AI, including incentivized reviews.Gumball Eyes
[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Bring back the gumballs eyes please 12334566888434678875336678875
From popsicle.com
Horrible downgrade
It’s miles down from the glory that these once were. It was nostalgia you were selling, now…well
From popsicle.com
No more gum ball eyes.
Would RecommendYa'll removed the gum ball eyes and that is It's the only reason that I'm writing this bad report. Because usually I'll make great popsicles.
From popsicle.com
Small and mini,no gumball eyes.
Popsicles are good but changed really fast no more gumball eyes and just went completely mini and small I think it’s a waste of time to do all that for only a few people complaints I don’t recommend buying them for them to be smaller than my hand and on a big stick.
From popsicle.com
horrible
Would Not Recommendbecause the chocolate chips are bad.. they need to bring back the gum balls.
From popsicle.com
Boycott till they bring gum all eyes back!!!
Would Not RecommendI will never buy another SpongeBob popsicle until they bring the gumball eyes back!!!
From popsicle.com
Disgusting
Would Not RecommendI got one from a gas station, no gumballs eyes and looks different than the old one
From popsicle.com
eyes
they need to bring back the gumball eyes. they are better and chocolate with fruit is nasty
From popsicle.com
Yumtastic
Would Recommend[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Super yummy I have always loved them since I was a kid. But they changed the eyes to chocolate now instead of gumballs and I feel like that was the wow factor. Why would I want a SpongeBob popsicle without the big gumball eyes. Cmon guys. Anywho I still love the popsicle though very yummy and I will always love SpongeBob.
From popsicle.com
I just bought the gumball popsicle for the first time in a few years When I first opened it I realized there was no eyes I was so mad I freaked out so please bring it back
From popsicle.com
Completely different
This used to be a big part of my childhood but they completely changed it. Made it smaller and tooo away yhe gum ball eyes and the mouth. They replaced it with cheap disgusting chocolate which completely contradicts the fruit punch and cotton candy flavor.
From popsicle.com
the people need the gumballs
Would Not RecommendNOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO THE GUMBALLSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS BOOOOOOOO
From popsicle.com
Don’t buy, no More gumballs
Would Not RecommendThey got rid of the gumball eyeballs. Never buying again. The gum was the best part
From popsicle.com
horrible decision
Would Not Recommendthey used to be my favorite, but after the gumballs were replaced with chocolate I haven't had a single one . bring back the gumball eyes !
From popsicle.com
Can’t get enough of the bobs
Great bob, love bobbin everyday, great serving sizes, 3 bobs a day gets me right.
From popsicle.com
NO MORE GUM BALL EYES???
Still love these but finding no gum balls in the eyes made me sooo sad! The chocolate eye balls need to go
From popsicle.com
chocolates should not be on fruity treat
Would Recommend[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I know the 2/5 is a stretch, but before the change of the eyes it was gonna be a 5/5. Honestly, having something you can’t chew on for multiple minutes after eating the ice cream just makes it unsatisfactory. The flavors are still the same, but the chocolate just combats the fruity flavor. So can you change it back or do you not wanna get sued. This is why the amount of people who buy your products has decreased.
From popsicle.com
Bring Back the GUMBALLS!
I have been getting this product since I was a child. Every summer I look forward to the ice cream truck to get this treat. Recently I’ve noticed each ice cream I got lacked the delicious gum ball eyes. Seeing today that there will no longer be gumball eyes is extremely disappointing. Chocolate doesn’t even go with this product. When you get a fruit punch drink, no one has it with a side of chocolate. So for a fruit punch ice cream product to have chocolate just doesn’t make sense. I really hope...
From popsicle.com
Bring Back The Gumballs
Would Not RecommendThe chocolate eyes don’t go well with the other flavors. The gumballs were so much better. Please bring them back.
From popsicle.com
bring back the gumball eyes, chocolate isnt workin
Would RecommendBring back the gumball eyes. The chocolate eyes are NOT working with the fruit punch/cotton candy flavoring like the grape flavored gumball did. I don't get it. If a great thing thats a fan favorite was working, WHY change a winning formula? That's actual melarchy. You ruined it. No wonder your pop sales are down. Please get over yourselves and bring back gumball eyes. Its better and works better than chocolate eyes.
From popsicle.com