Ratings & Reviews for Architectural Mailboxes Elite Large Metal Large Mailbox Black
Ratings may include incentivized customer reviews.
What Customers Are Saying
Customers overwhelmingly praise this mailbox for its sturdy, well-built construction and generous capacity for mail and small packages. Most highlight the durable metal build, excellent paint finish, and spacious design that accommodates modern delivery needs. Many appreciate the straightforward installation and mounting hardware included. Reviewers consistently describe it as excellent value for the price, with solid construction that exceeds expectations. A few report receiving damaged units or note the door doesn't stay fully closed, but these concerns are vastly outweighed by positive feedback. Overall, most customers consider it a reliable, practical choice.
Customer review summary generated by AI, including incentivized reviews.Good value
Would RecommendSolid construction. Good installation directions.
Priced well, good quality.
Would RecommendGreat Product
Mailbox door and hinge are weak.
Would Not RecommendWe've had this mailbox for 2 years and the hinge is tight and has rusted. Now it causes the weak steel of the door to bend instead of moving the hinge. I've done everything to lubricate it but the steel door is too weak to overcome the resistance in the hinge. The mailbox is otherwise in good shape. It's just very cheaply built. All it needs is a little bit of a stronger gauge steel on the door and it would be fine.
Verified Pro
Try mounting from inside mounting holes
Would RecommendLarge capacity
Meets Jones Creek specs.
Would RecommendIt had to meet Jones Creek specs, which it does, a very large and well made box.
Nice Mailbox
Would Not RecommendNice mailbox
It won't stay shut
Would Not RecommendWhile the mailbox looks nice, it constantly falls open. My mail has gotten soaked in the rain, and I've had mail blow out.
Looks great
Would RecommendPerfect size
Verified Purchaser
No screws included
Wish it came with the correct size of mounting screws. Our neighbor requires this X-Large mailbox. This is our 3rd in 5 years it’s so big our mail person keeps smashing into it and there is no recourse. Wish there. Was a stronger version available in the club size
Mailbox
Would RecommendIt’s a mailbox. Perfect for what I needed. No complaints!
Exactly as it appears online
Would RecommendThis is a basic mailbox, but you can see that. With that in mind, it serves its purpose. I haven’t had it long enough to know how it will hold up.
Verified Purchaser
Good basic mailbox
Would RecommendLike the simplicity of this mailbox, it fits my needs.
Large mailbox
This is a large solid mailbox. My mailman stuffs it full all the time. It is easy to install and holds up well in weather. Only reason i had to get a new one is a plow took mine out over the winter. Only con i have found is over time the hinge gets week and allows door to flop open.
Bent in shipping
Would Not RecommendMailbox was bent when I received it. Box was in tact, back of the mailbox is bent up