Ratings & Reviews for Weber Genesis Crafted Carbon steel Griddle

Rusts too easily

I definitely cared for this item. Stored it indoors, but it still will collect small bits of rust. I wouldn’t trust cooking on this as quality seems low.

Perfect Griddle

Perfect size for two people to use and made well.

Satisfied

Works well. Adds a whole new element to my grill abilities. Has not rusted yet with very minimal prep and care.

Almost Perfect

Excellent griddle! Level cooking surface!! The only improvement I could recommend would be to widen the waste discharge slot to make it easier to clear the grill when cleaning!! We have done burgers as well as shrimp and veggies!! Very useful to our style of dining!!

Great griddle insert for your Weber dBBQ grill

The quality you would expect from Weber. Highly recommend

Quick to rust

We bought this last summer and always follow the cleaning and seasoning instructions. This summer we used it once and then cleaned, seasoned and stored it for a few weeks. Went to use it again and the finish is peeling off and rust was underneath. Don’t feel comfortable using it anymore. Very bummed because we really enjoyed the new things we could cook with the griddle insert. Not worth the price if it needs to be replaced every year.

They don’t make them better than this!

Heavy, well-crafted, great seasoning/conditioning directions, works perfectly on my,now 10+ year old, 3-burner weber on top of the grates. Sides are just the right height to contain liquids while still allowing some to vent through the provided slot.

Rust issues

I bought this earlier in the year. I followed the directions carefully to make sure the griddle was seasoned properly. I LOVE the way it works - it's heavy as heck but it works great. The only issue I have is RUST! I clean it according to the directions, make sure it is completely dry before stowing it away in the accessory cabinet on the side. The grill is completely covered so no water is getting in. Why is this happening? I know see that you are promoting a line of "rust proof griddles...

Griddle insert for 325s

Absolutely love this purchase. I use my griddle 4-5 times a week. Don’t know why waited so long. Had mine for about7 months.

Great addition to our grill

The flat top griddle insert is the perfect addition to our Weber grill. Make sure you season it before use and you will have no issues. You can still use the grill while at the same time, you can use the flat top. It’s perfect for cooking up veggies, eggs, bacon, grilled sandwiches & delicious smash burgers. Be aware that the flat top griddle gets hotter than the regular grill so burgers will cook faster. Also, you should cook with the grill lid open for best results.

Rust and more rust

Love Weber products, but this griddle just keeps rusting, I've seasoned it according to instructions, cleaned properly, re-oiled (seasoned) put away dry in covered grill, go to use it and its showing rust again, Maybe I hit a bad production run, but I'm back to using a cast iron skillet on top of grill.