Ratings may include incentivized customer reviews.
What Customers Are Saying
Customers overwhelmingly praise the perfect balance of smooth milk chocolate and creamy peanut butter filling as the defining feature. Many note holiday-shaped varieties contain more peanut butter and taste superior to classic versions. Reviewers consistently highlight the exceptional texture—described as creamy and melting—and emphasize that freezing enhances the experience. The seasonal shapes add visual appeal and festive enjoyment, with customers calling them their favorite. A few mention taste preference concerns, but these are vastly outweighed by enthusiastic satisfaction across nearly all feedback.
Customer review summary generated by AI, including incentivized reviews.Would buy again
These are so good. Side chocolate. No aftertaste or brittle flavor. Easy to open package. Great mixture of chocolate and peanut butter! You can smell the filling when you bite into it .
From influenster.com
Best candy!
My favorite candy hands down! We love to freeze them in our family. They are such a good mix of peanut butter and chocolate. We love to freeze them or melt them on our Smores instead of other chocolate!
From influenster.com
Super delicious
I love Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups! The chocolate is smooth and the peanut butter filling is rich and creamy. They have the perfect balance of sweet and salty, making them one of my favorite treats. I would definitely buy them again.
From influenster.com
Love these things!
The amount that my family loves these is actually hilarious. Watching my husband run to the candy aisle when these drop for Easter is comical. Great flavor and texture just like the classic packaging, just shaped like eggs. Store them in the freezer for an extra special treat!
From influenster.com
Great Combo of flavor
Smooth peanut butter consistency covered in chocolate!! Omg its smooth texture with every mouthful will have you wanting more. Peanut butter & chocolate what a great combo!!!
From influenster.com
Yum
Love these! My favorite kind if reeses are the holiday ones! Its the perfect peanubutter to chocolate ratio. Melts in your mouth good! Super fresh.
From influenster.com
Taste
These spook-a-lishes chocolate covered, peanut butter filled pumpkins will have you enjoy the sweet taste combined. Sealed in a multi-package to keep in freshness and large size to give you a lot to enjoy.
From influenster.com
Yum
The Reese’s milk, chocolate, peanut butter cups are one of my favorite chocolate candies.  I love them and all sizes but the snack size is perfect to take with my lunch or Buy for trick-or-treaters.
From influenster.com
Perfection
The shapes Reese’s are my absolute fave! They’re flat out delicious! I wish they had them year round! The eggs are the best of all! The chocolate to pb ratio is perfect
From influenster.com
tastes like oil not peanut butter
Would Not Recommendi had some reeses today and they tasted like oil. there was zero peanut butter taste.
From hersheyland.com
Very fresh and was great little snack
Was awesome fresh !! It comes in individual packaging which makes it very beneficial for a snack and not have to waste ! They was so good I went back and bought more !!
From influenster.com
Creamy and Dreamy
I love these. They melt in your mouth and a perfect balance of peanut butter and chocolate. They don't stick to the roof of your mouth like plain peanut butter. The only problem is not eating the whole bag in one sitting.
From influenster.com
NOT GF
Kids like these but say they are different choclate AND peanut butter than the eggs or original cups. PB is clumpy and sticky. Please make all of your seasonal items with the gluten free label
From influenster.com
Adorable
Delicious!! I mean what can I say it’s Reese’s and it’s amazing. So soft and creamy. I enjoy them at room temperature but I also enjoy them semi frozen, such a nice little summer treat. I highly recommend these! The shapes are adorable too who doesn’t love a cute pumpkin
From influenster.com
best sweet and salty combo!
perfect balance between sweet and salty! the melting chocolate feels amazing mixed with the peanut butter. perfect for when i’m craving something sweet, but not too sweet.
From influenster.com
MY FAVORITE!
Pumpkins were my very first holiday Reese's and they are the best!!!! The perfect balance of peanut butter to chocolate ratio! The salty sweet goodness, the pumpkin is a great size and it doesn't melt too fast, but just enough!
From influenster.com
One of the best Reese’s shapes there is!
One of the best Reese’s shapes there is! Also the texture on the pumpkins is one of the best in the world of Reese’s. The chocolate to peanut butter ratio is unmatched and these will nearly melt in your mouth. I always look forwards to these in the fall along with the nice Halloween vibe packaging. As always the price on these bad boys is more than fair.
From influenster.com
Delicious
I love Reeses since always but this presentation it blows my mind, I cant wait to Halloween and Try one of these, have a really good taste and texture
From influenster.com
Reese's anything mean nom nom
The pumpkin shape is adorable, perfect for fall and trick or treating. The cost per amount can tend range higher than other candies, but its Reese's. The amount of peanut butter to chocolate is perfect. It is firm not crumbling.
From influenster.com
BEST CANDY EVER
Greatest candy to ever exist! The freshness and ratio of PB to chocolate is perfect. It has a perfect melt in your mouth feeling. Great smell with the chocolate and PB. Plus it is so cute when it looks like a pumpkin
From influenster.com