Ratings may include incentivized customer reviews.
What Customers Are Saying
This toaster generally receives positive feedback for its even toasting, attractive design, and convenient features like the bagel setting and individual crumb trays. Many customers highlight the product's durability, with some noting it has lasted over 15 years. However, some users have experienced issues with uneven toasting, difficulty lowering the toast levers, and inconsistent performance. Additionally, a few found the slots too narrow to accommodate thicker bread slices. While the majority of customers are satisfied, there are some quality control and design concerns that need to be addressed.
Customer review summary generated by AI, including incentivized reviews.4 slice toaster
Would Recommend[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Love the toaster 2nd one i bought in the last 5 years
From cuisinart.com
Lousy toaster CPT-435P1
[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Doesn’t brown any type of bread, muffin, bagel unless toasted twice
From cuisinart.com
Toasty!
Great toasting following review comments to adjust level for bagels (5-6) and English muffins (6) after a couple of test rounds. Same for bread toasting requiring (4-5) level to your desired doneness. Toast carriage lift feature very convenient for English muffins and bagels. I like the signal when done while tending other breakfast tasks. Looking forward to reheating homemade waffles.
From cuisinart.com
Delighted!
Would RecommendI’m delighted with my toaster! I have been a Cuisinart fan for years…my last toaster lasted almost 10 years and that’s why I’m a repeat customer. Their products are high quality, designed well and the longevity of their products keeps me coming back
From cuisinart.com
Buyer beware….Only one side toasts!
Would Not Recommend[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] My original toaster was the best but quit working properly. Cuisinart replaced with a similar model and it wouldn’t toast properly. After going through troubleshooting with the company, they deemed it defective. They replaced with this model at which only toasts one side of the bread! I have plugged into several different outlets, tried different slots at different intervals and still only one side toasts!! I have ALL Cuisinart appliances ...
From cuisinart.com
We’re very sorry to hear about your experience and understand your frustration, especially after multiple replacements. In addition to trying differen... Read More
New favorite toaster
Would RecommendAbsolutely love this new toaster. Does sliced bread or bagels perfectly.
From cuisinart.com
Perfect toast every time
The toaster is not only attractive but it has a setting that is easy to choose the correct number for toast, muffins and bagels. Numbers 4 is perfect for toast but number 5 or 6 makes perfect English muffins.
From cuisinart.com
Digital toaster
Would Not RecommendHold off on this for a bit, the toaster isn’t worth the price
From cuisinart.com
Thank you for your feedback—we’re sorry to hear the toaster did not meet your expectations in terms of performance and value. We understand how import... Read More
Just Right for Me
Would RecommendI'm extremely happy with this toaster. It has just the right balance of features and simplicity. Its Bagel, Reheat, and Defrost are the most useful features for a toaster -- anything more is superfluous for most people. I really like the LCD display that counts down even though I prefer analog controls in my car dashboards and clocks. My only suggestion is to make the beeping at the end of the toasting optional. Very few people are going to leave the kitchen when toasting is active and the t...
From cuisinart.com
Infuriating completion bell
Would Not RecommendA very nice toaster ruined by the unnecessary and unwanted completion bell that is so loud that the unit is unusable until everyone in the house is fully awake. And bonus - there is no way to silence it!
From cuisinart.com
Thank you for sharing your candid feedback—we’re sorry to hear the completion bell volume negatively impacted your experience with the toaster. Audibl... Read More
Excellent Choice!!!
Would RecommendLove this toaster! Nice heavy duty unit. Toasts perfectly! It rings when toast is done! Love it!
From cuisinart.com
Great Bread & Bagel Toaster
Would RecommendThis is a Great Bread & Bagel Toaster! The slide out crumb trays are awesome. After one gets used to the new appliance, it is easy to use all the fabulous settings. I have not “over done” any breads yet!
From cuisinart.com
We're sorry to hear the Cuisinart 4 Slice Countdown Metal Toaster is not delivering the browning performance you expected. For best results, we recomm... Read More