Ratings & Reviews for Cafe Black 2 -Slice Toaster

Broke after only a few uses.

I received this toaster as a gift for Christmas. It broke only after a few uses. It appears the carriage assembly isn’t very sturdy and bent very easily just from popping up. I did get a replacement toaster as it was still covered by warranty. I suggest GE find a better quality supplier.

Looks nice

Nothing great, Average toaster than looks nice Will see how long it lasts

Great Toaster

Best toaster I’ve ever used. It gets hot and creates the desired effectiveness evenly and quickly. It looks good too. we have matching GE Cafe appliances (stove, refrigerator and dishwasher)

not that great

still learning settings, but don't like the heating performance, works best when pushing the frozen button. If set at 8 it does not toast bread comes out barely toasted. Not worth the money, I would buy something else if I knew.

Great Design

Love the design and performance so far. Hope it lasts long!!!

Gorgeous Toaster

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Gorgeous, sleek, and toasts well. It really pops with my other appliances.

Looks great

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Looks great in my kitchen and the versatility to toast and cook frozen food is great!

So Much More Than A Toaster

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] We love the simplicity of the toaster. Easy to use and the color and style fits with the Cafe wall oven and Cafe Smart microwave. Cleaning the crumb tray is so much easier with the door to the side of the toaster. Making toast is considerably faster than a traditional toaster. The controls are at your fingertips and easy to use. The 2 slot capacity is large enough for a bagel and therefore big enough for any size toast you want to make.

Disappointed in quality

I have one toaster and it no longer toasts on all 4 sides

won’t last long

Nice looking but terrible quality otherwise. This gave out after about 2 years. For the price point, I shouldn’t have to buy a new toaster every other year. It doesn’t leave our counter and stays plugged into the same outlet, so it hasn’t had a hard life. Extremely disappointing.

Great Features, Awesome Colors, High Performance.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I just Love the Cafe line. I have the matte black fridge, stove, microwave and the toaster. Next is the dishwasher 🩷🖤love them all🫶thank you GE for making this beautiful, super high tech, multi functional kitchen appliances. Don’t stop making them cause I need the dishwasher in matte black 🤣

Timeless elegance with modern features

This is a beautiful toaster with retro elegance and black/copper design enhances any kitchen decor. It has many modern features and works with bread, bagels and waffles. What more could you ask for? I've only had the toaster for a few weeks but the performance is very good and the results seem consistent. Hopefully it works this well for years to come.

Great Features and design

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] What drove me to buy this toaster was the modern design and the versatility of it. Combines perfectly with my kitchen style. I hope the price will be worth.

feature

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I love this toaster, especially the express feature. Unfortunately. the inside coils aren't working anymore.

Finally found a great toaster!

Here’s a case of “You get what you pay for”. I wasn’t happy with the toasters I bought in a department store. I finally found one that’s attractive and a keeper. My only complaint is that I thought I had to buy the crumb tray separately. I thought it was odd that the toaster wouldn’t come with one. It did. Don’t buy the tray alone.

Love Cafe brand!

I have used this toaster only a few times since delivery in July 15, 2025. I like that it has several options (bagel, express finish, reheat, frozen), although I have yet to explore them. It has a crumb tray which is a bonus! So far, I have had no issues with it. Love the white color!

Died 13 months, worthless now, avoid this toaster

I think this toaster is overpriced and terrible quality since it made it just barely over the warranty, I'm not going to even try to get GE to do anything because they never do, buyer beware!

Love how it matches my Cafe appliances!

I have the Cafe fridge, microwave and stove which I love and wanted a new toaster to match it and my old toaster was not doing its job. I have only used this one a few times but it works great so far. I have tried an English muffin and regular bread and it toasts perfectly. It will take some time to get the correct adjustments but I will experiment. It does look fetching sitting on the counter next to the appliances....that is all important!

Beautifully designed and works great!

This is our favorite toaster yet! It looks pretty on our counter and toasts to perfection! It’s easy to use and nicely fits large slices of bread and wide bagels!

Nice appearance

It has a nice appearance, works well. But it’s cheaply made for the price