Ratings may include incentivized customer reviews.
What Customers Are Saying
Customers overwhelmingly praise the perfect balance of smooth milk chocolate and creamy peanut butter filling as the defining feature. Many note holiday-shaped varieties contain more peanut butter and taste superior to classic versions. Reviewers consistently highlight the exceptional texture—described as creamy and melting—and emphasize that freezing enhances the experience. The seasonal shapes add visual appeal and festive enjoyment, with customers calling them their favorite. A few mention taste preference concerns, but these are vastly outweighed by enthusiastic satisfaction across nearly all feedback.
Customer review summary generated by AI, including incentivized reviews.The best shape
These have incredible flavor! I love the holiday Reese’s! They are the perfect size to be satisfied after eating one or two of them! They have a nice and rich peanut butter filling.
From influenster.com
Lots of peanut butter and perfect amount too just
Would RecommendMy favorite, delicious, I wish they had this out all year it’s sooooooo good
From hersheyland.com
My favorite pumpkin is a Reece’s pumpkin
My favorite season and my favorite treat! The chocolate and peanut butter are such a good combination and I love the pumpkin shape! They always hit the spot. Can’t wait to get more!
From influenster.com
Love Reeses but size portion is horrible
Would RecommendI absolutely love reeses.. can't wait every year for Easter Egg...Pumpkin and Christmas tree but I am very disappointed in the size of these candies...I understand the cost of things but when size gets smaller and price keeps rising I am not a fan of that..
From hersheyland.com
so so good
insanely good. so delicious and soft and chewy with that classic chocolate outside. such a good value purchase every year for easter baskets and secret pantry snacks.
From influenster.com
delicious
always the classic ingredients, time has proven this simple yet utterly delicious mixture of all time favorites peanut butter and chocolate together. melts in your mouth and hands, and always leaves you wanting the fresh smooth combo.
From influenster.com
all time favorite
the cutest little snack sized pumpkins, you almost feel bad eating them. they are so addicting. the smell of the chocolate and peanut butter is as always unmatched.
From influenster.com
So good!
A staple in our home everytime around Halloween. Perfect ratio of peanut butter & chocolate. They are so soft & the perfect amount of saltiness. Wish the shape was a little more prominent but great anyways!
From influenster.com
Read me 🤓
So I might have purchased 3 or 4 of these jumbo bags....🥴 These reeses pumpkins are so good. Nice salty sweet and smooth. I like the festive pumpkin shape even though he's the lil blob that could.. tiny stump of a pumpkin stem 🤓 I stocked up for Halloween and took advantage of a major sale in August. My intuition was right... them Halloween prices are 😱🧟♂️👹 What you know bout an early jump scare? I make sure to have these bags in a cooler temp if I can help it. These lil guys will melt ea...
From influenster.com
Delicious!
The texture of these is just AMAZING I love Reese’s but this really takes the win for me! It’s so salty and sweet and the feel of the peanut butter is a delicacy.
From influenster.com
🤤
I love anything reese… but i get these to make smores with GAME CHANGER🤭!!! If you havent tried… run…. Dont walk to the nearest store and make a smores
From influenster.com
Reese's Peanut Butter Milk Chocolate Pumpkins
SPOOKY SEASON! I look forward to these every year at halloween! Reese's always a favorite every holiday with my family. So delicious and soft creamy peanubutter with a yummy chocolate shell, taste really good also for all the peanut butter fans. The packaging is small so it can fit in your pocket or in your purse, perfect for on the go. My favorite sweet treat snack, it’s dangerous how tasty they are!! 😄
From influenster.com
Soft chocolate and heaps of peanut butter
These are my favourite of the Reese varieties and what I look forward to devouring around Halloween. The chocolate is much softer than a typical Reese’s cup and perhaps a greater peanut butter to chocolate ratio. Delicious!!
From influenster.com
Very tasty
These snacks are always good. They usually come out around the holidays. I like them. Plenty of peanut butter. The grand kids love them to.cant go wrong.
From influenster.com
Easy treat for littles
The recipe has changed over the years but my toddler loves them and so does his little brother. The protein helps balance the chocolate and makes it the right amount of sweet.
From influenster.com
My husband’s favorite!
My husband’s absolute favorite candy! It’s the perfect ratio or chocolate to peanut butter, and bite-size cups. I love to get these for him as an occasional treat.
From influenster.com
!!Nothing Better!!
What is better than peanut butter and chocolate?!? Nothing! Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups are simply the best candy out there. The orange packaging is iconic. And it’s the perfect mixture of sweet and creamy. Worth the calories since I think there’s protein in peanut butter- right?
From influenster.com